Should I buy a MES30 even if I have a propane version?

[Faarg]

So, I just recently got into smoking and am hooked. 100% hooked. I ended up going with the Masterbuilt propane as my first smoker but didn't put a lot of thought into the purchase. I like it but I will most likely upgrade at some point to a "real" smoker. But, for the interim I'm gonna have a lot of fun with my current smoker.

But, one thing that I've noticed, is that I want to smoke two things at one time and temps, etc. don't always align with the two smokes. So having a second smoker isn't a bad thing -- come on guys, you 've been there before.

So, here's where I'm at. I recently learned of a really good deal on a used MES30 like the one below:

https://foxandgrapes.co/products/ma...tal-electric-smoker-with-leg-kit-cover-and-gl

Should I get it? I'm leaning towards a heck yeah right now. I know that there are several posts on here about how to tell if it's a version 1 or version 2 or 2.5. And Bearcarver has given several great posts on how to tell them apart. But I'm not sure that my decision will be based on version number. Just more of an issue of how I'm gonna slide this smoker in beside my grill and current smoker without too much hassle from the wife.

 

[biteme7951]

I have one of each, it just depends on my mood that day. plus the propane is good for hotter smokes and the electric is good at lower temps.

Barry.

 

[zwiller]

Barry covered it but I went from MB gasser to MES and will never go back. I prefer the accuracy of the MES. Gasser always needed fiddling. Some guys might enjoy that but I wanted set and forget. MES is also insulated and I smoked all winter long with no issues. No way that would happen with the gasser. You will need an AMNPS for the MES.

 

[SonnyE]

Reluctantly, I say no.
I would recommend you get a larger electric like a MES 40, or maybe jump into something like a Smokin It.
Obviously you are liking your Propane Smoker. So instead of stepping sideways, step up into a larger unit.

I say this reluctantly because I'm the kind to get the right sized tool for the job. I can't ever see me filling even my MES 30. I mean, I sure haven't come close yet, anyway. 2-3 racks max for me, often a single rack.
But, for me, a smoker is a smoking device. Not an oven.
YMMV

 

[Bearcarver]

So, I just recently got into smoking and am hooked. 100% hooked. I ended up going with the Masterbuilt propane as my first smoker but didn't put a lot of thought into the purchase. I like it but I will most likely upgrade at some point to a "real" smoker. But, for the interim I'm gonna have a lot of fun with my current smoker.

But, one thing that I've noticed, is that I want to smoke two things at one time and temps, etc. don't always align with the two smokes. So having a second smoker isn't a bad thing -- come on guys, you 've been there before.

So, here's where I'm at. I recently learned of a really good deal on a used MES30 like the one below:

https://foxandgrapes.co/products/ma...tal-electric-smoker-with-leg-kit-cover-and-gl



Should I get it? I'm leaning towards a heck yeah right now. I know that there are several posts on here about how to tell if it's a version 1 or version 2 or 2.5. And Bearcarver has given several great posts on how to tell them apart. But I'm not sure that my decision will be based on version number. Just more of an issue of how I'm gonna slide this smoker in beside my grill and current smoker without too much hassle from the wife.

I agree that the MES 40 would be much better, but if you're getting a really good price for it, go for it !!

After all it is a Gen #2.5, which is the Absolute best MES so far.

Tell your wife, "Bear gave you permission".


Bear

 

[Faarg]

I agree that the MES 40 would be much better, but if you're getting a really good price for it, go for it !!

After all it is a Gen #2.5, which is the Absolute best MES so far.

Tell your wife, "Bear gave you permission".


Bear

Thanks for the info. I was hoping that it was the 2.5 but wasn't quite sure. The part that was making me think that it wasn't was that I thought that all 2.5s were bluetooth and had the bluetooth logo. And there is no sun shield on the control panel. But there seem to be hundreds of different variations of the MES.

So I told the wife that Bear told me to get it and she said ok. Well, that and she may not have to worry about me burning down the house on overnight smokes.

One thought that I've been having for brisket (and other meats) is starting off the smoke in the propane so that I have a shot at getting the smoke ring and then moving it to the MES for the nighttime portion of the smoke. My only concern is that I really don't want to transfer the meat but people do it all the time when they wrap so it shouldn't be a major issue.

 

[Bearcarver]

Thanks for the info. I was hoping that it was the 2.5 but wasn't quite sure. The part that was making me think that it wasn't was that I thought that all 2.5s were bluetooth and had the bluetooth logo. And there is no sun shield on the control panel. But there seem to be hundreds of different variations of the MES.

So I told the wife that Bear told me to get it and she said ok. Well, that and she may not have to worry about me burning down the house on overnight smokes.

One thought that I've been having for brisket (and other meats) is starting off the smoke in the propane so that I have a shot at getting the smoke ring and then moving it to the MES for the nighttime portion of the smoke. My only concern is that I really don't want to transfer the meat but people do it all the time when they wrap so it shouldn't be a major issue.

Yeah, They screw around with switching parts from one to another.
I see it doesn't even have the slots that a sun shield would snap into.
The other important Gen #2.5 things are all there:
Top Vent on the back left of the top, instead of back right.
Split level water pan, and not the full, slanted drip plate (like the Gen #2 has).
Hinged left.

Note: I never sleep when my MES is running, but mine is on my wood front porch, on a wood platform, in front of an all wood front wall, under a wood ceiling, on an all wood log house.

Bear

 

[biteme7951]

Yeah, They screw around with switching parts from one to another.
I see it doesn't even have the slots that a sun shield would snap into.
The other important Gen #2.5 things are all there:
Top Vent on the back left of the top, instead of back right.
Split level water pan, and not the full, slanted drip plate (like the Gen #2 has).
Hinged left.

Note: I never sleep when my MES is running, but mine is on my wood front porch, on a wood platform, in front of an all wood front wall, under a wood ceiling, on an all wood log house.

Bear

You woodn't want to risk it, wood you?

Barry.

 

[Faarg]

You woodn't want to risk it, wood you?

Barry.

He's got some impressive wood.

 

[biteme7951]

He's got some impressive wood.

Ummmm......TMIo_O

 

[SonnyE]

Note: I never sleep when my MES is running, but mine is on my wood front porch, on a wood platform, in front of an all wood front wall, under a wood ceiling, on an all wood log house.

Oh, that's bad.
I do sleep during my overnight runs.
But my MES lives on bricks, by a block wall, in my "outdoor Kitchen" area, and I have insurance. LOL! ;)

 

[Bearcarver]

Oh, that's bad.
I do sleep during my overnight runs.
But my MES lives on bricks, by a block wall, in my "outdoor Kitchen" area, and I have insurance. LOL! ;)

On Bricks & a block wall would be much safer than wood, but I'd rather not collect on my insurance.
I hope you were joking that having insurance would make it OK to run a Smoker overnight, while sleeping.

I know some MES units have lit up in the past, and I try to let "MES Newbies" know that is a possibility.

Bear

 

[Faarg]

I agree that the MES 40 would be much better, but if you're getting a really good price for it, go for it !!

After all it is a Gen #2.5, which is the Absolute best MES so far.

Tell your wife, "Bear gave you permission".


Bear

I had wanted something like the 40 because I have had to squeeze in my briskets (all 2 of them) at the start of smokes. But ended up finding this one for $60 and it had only been used once so I couldn't resist.

 

[Bearcarver]

$60 for a Gen #2.5 MES 30 !!!!

That's a hard deal to find without a gun & a mask!!!

Bear

 

[mike243]

I cant say I have ever tasted a smoke ring but I do get them with the pellet grill,get great taste with my 40mes without 1 lot of work for presentation imo

 

[Faarg]

I just finished my second smoke with the MES (Boston Butt) and very happy with the results. This second cook taught me one thing -- I was overly concerned with mild temperature fluctuations before. On my propane smoker I kept tweaking the gas flow until the smoker was basically pinned at 225 (or something nearby). And this would have me tweaking the valves a few times each hour. However, with the MES, the temperature fluctuated from 218-243 the whole time (as the MES turned on and off the heating element) and the Butt came out perfectly. So maybe I need to stress less with the propane smoker and focus on a general range rather than a precise temp.

I'm sure that this is basic for most of the people here but it was an "aha" moment for me this weekend.

 

[Bearcarver]

I just finished my second smoke with the MES (Boston Butt) and very happy with the results. This second cook taught me one thing -- I was overly concerned with mild temperature fluctuations before. On my propane smoker I kept tweaking the gas flow until the smoker was basically pinned at 225 (or something nearby). And this would have me tweaking the valves a few times each hour. However, with the MES, the temperature fluctuated from 218-243 the whole time (as the MES turned on and off the heating element) and the Butt came out perfectly. So maybe I need to stress less with the propane smoker and focus on a general range rather than a precise temp.

I'm sure that this is basic for most of the people here but it was an "aha" moment for me this weekend.

That sounds pretty good.
I try to get the top & bottom of the cycle to have the Temp I want in the middle of the cycle.
Like 225° would be about 218° to 232°, or 213° to 237°, and sometimes it's even 223° to 227°.

Bear