Here is a list of lump ratings from readers of the site, rather than from those who run the site:
The site states: We suggest that you vote after every bag of lump that you use. If a brand's quality is going up or down, this should eventually be reflected in their ratings.
If you go through and read the comments from readers, each comment is dated. For example, a fairly recent comment on Royal Oak Lump Charcoal: Quality has fallen WAY off over the past year. Mostly chips and dust now. (07/14/22)
and
Royal Oak was good but now awful. Last six bags had rocks, 65% very small pieces, and 5% very large pieces. Cheap but useless. (03/15/22)
The Lump Charcoal Database Rankings-- Naked Whiz Charcoal Ceramic Cooking
Readers rate many brands of lump charcoal.
www.nakedwhiz.com
The site states: We suggest that you vote after every bag of lump that you use. If a brand's quality is going up or down, this should eventually be reflected in their ratings.
If you go through and read the comments from readers, each comment is dated. For example, a fairly recent comment on Royal Oak Lump Charcoal: Quality has fallen WAY off over the past year. Mostly chips and dust now. (07/14/22)
and
Royal Oak was good but now awful. Last six bags had rocks, 65% very small pieces, and 5% very large pieces. Cheap but useless. (03/15/22)
Last edited: