Yet another McRib experiment

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

mdboatbum

Master of the Pit
Original poster
OTBS Member
Apr 22, 2011
4,117
541
Washington, DC
Not terribly long ago, I was scrounging for lunch in the fridge. I found a leftover smoked bratwurst and a hoagie roll. Heated up the bratwurst, cut it in half lengthwise, put it on the roll, doused it in BBQ sauce, added some diced onion and some pickle and found it not entirely unlike a McRib. The texture was a bit off, but the seasoning was close. Been thinking about that for a while, so decided to try something.

Got a package of uncooked bratwurst and removed the casings. Divided the 5 links into 2 half pound patties, roughly the size and shape of a hoagie roll.
IMG_0968.jpg


While I was at it I made some half pound beef burgers.

IMG_0965.jpg


Then put them on the WSM over kingsford blue and hickory chunks at 275. Took about an hour and a half to come to 155.

IMG_0975.jpg


Seasoned everything with a little SPOG. Was gonna sear them, but when they came to temp, they looked ok so didn't bother.

IMG_0977.jpg


I know a lot of you will recoil in horror at a burger at 155, but I have a nearly 90 year old living the house, so have to keep a close eye on things. After a 20 minute rest, everything was at 165, so it was time to build my sandwich.

IMG_6371.jpg



It wasn't exactly like a McRib, but it was a pretty good sandwich! The flavor of the sausage was just about spot on. The original is essentially a mild sausage seasoned with rosemary essence, and this was pretty close to that. The original uses liquid smoke, this had hickory smoke. Their sauce is sweet and sticky, all I had on hand was a doctored up Carolina mustard sauce which was just fine. The pickles and onions were PERFECT!!
All kidding aside, it was basically a mcrib with the volume turned up to 11. It was bigger with bigger more prominent flavors. If I do it again, which I probably will, I think I'll cut the size in half and use a more middle of the road sauce as well as a milder wood like pecan.
Thanks for looking!
 
I like it . Looks great . I do all my burger meat well done . No issue for me with that .
Cooked and seasoned right it's fine .
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdboatbum
Great round of meat.
I was never fond of a McRib, but my son sure ate enough of them in the day. I tried to duplicate them, but never got it to his liking.
Kudos to you

All of my ground meat goes to just done. Still juicy & flavorful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdboatbum
I like the McRib. Did a thread on it a long time ago. Recently I found some cups of bbq sauce to dip my chicken nuggets in at our cafe at work and the bbq sauce tasted like what was on the McRib. I added it to my notes to try it in the future. It was Bulls Eye original BBQ sauce.
 
Been too long since I had a mcrib to know if I like them but I'd definitely help eat your sandwiches!

Ryan
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdboatbum
I guess for me the idea of a McRib is no different than a Filet-o-Fish or anything else from a fastfood joint...it will never hit my stomach no matter what it tastes like.

That being said if you can mimic that at home then great but I'll stick with real ribs,hand made burgers and a filet that actually is a filet.
 
"I know a lot of you will recoil in horror at a burger at 155"

Depends on who's making it. Anyone but me and I'll take it gray, I dont know where in the heck they got that meat from! I grind all my own burgers from chuck so I know its one muscle and I like it to bleed out on the plate before assembly! Actually its myoglobin...

I would eat what you made before a McRib any day. I think I had a double cheeseburger from McDonald's several months ago, for some reason...I think I thought it would be fast, but man, a lot of people eat that stuff, so nothing fast at our McDonald's! That's the first time I had been to a McDonald's in years, and probably the last for a very long time. Don't get me wrong, the burgers are tasty, but If I'm splurging on take out, McDonald's just aint a splurge to me...plus, everything from that place is a laxative for my body:emoji_anguished:

I think I had the McRib once, years ago. Never understood the hoopla. But a brat burger? Imma have to do that! Cooked gray...because I have no idea where that meat came from 😬
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdboatbum
Looks delish! I love sausage samis. If you have some Italian sausage…patty that up with motz and marinara.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdboatbum
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Clicky