As long as they are alive....I would eat them. If they are dead, I’m reluctant to eat them. My neighbor caught them and iced them down for transportation. It kind of keeps them fresh and slows their metabolic rate (their not eating so they are feeding on the meat in their body = not as full/meaty) and it keeps them from molting (sheading their shell= Soft shell crabs= fantastic meal!!) These are good, but I think the best crabs I ever ate were fresh out of the water. I took the kids fishing a couple years ago and the fish were not biting. So we bought a couple crab traps and some chicken legs (cheap). We turned them loose to catch some… The first day they had so many crabs we lost count. I was giving them away, but the 2[sup]nd[/sup] day I told them I would boil them some if they wanted. By the end of the day we had about 12 dozen that we cooked. We ate all we could, gave some away and still and some to take home the next day….man that was fun though!!!!