Am i losing it?

Discussion in 'Pork' started by dougmays, May 14, 2012.

  1. dougmays

    dougmays Limited Mod Group Lead

    So i'm having a inner-personal-conflict with my BBQ skills....questioning life and all that stuff...

    i consider myself pretty knowledgeable...i have cook many briskets, butts, ribs, chickens and jerky. i know my smoker well and i know the science of smoking pretty well. So here is my problem...i did a friendly backyard smokeout a few weeks ago. i  knew we only had until 5pm on a saturday to complete the pork and pull and ready to be judged.

    So my plan was buy a smaller butt and start early...i'd rather be done way early and let it rest in foil and a towel and let it break down more until i'm ready for judging. I get to the cookout at 6am saturday me 11 hours of cook time! I bought a smaller butt just to make sure i'd be done in time, i got a 3.5lber. so in theory my cooking at 225 should take at most 7-8 hours. 

    i had one of the smaller of course i got flack from my friends about that. so we all get our butts in..i was the 2nd or 3rd to get mine in a smoking. others had slightly larger butts then me and started after me.

    long story short as time draws near my friends are finishing around me...hitting temps of 185-200. i'm sitting there at 2-3pm sitting at 175 and barely inching forward. finally 4pm comes around and i'm almost at 180. i say screw it i want atleast a hour of resting...i know it'll go up in temp atleast 5 degrees so i wrap and pput in my cooler to rest.

    i get it out and it pulls away fine but i know i've had more tender meat.

    So i guess my question competition (or in general cooking) am i really being naive to keep at 225 the whole time? i'm thinking of starting out my smokes for now on at 250...and once i get over the peak setting it lower down to 225 to finish off.

    maybe i just had a un-agreeable butt...who knows...but i'm getting down on myself here
  2. jirodriguez

    jirodriguez Master of the Pit OTBS Member SMF Premier Member

    Probably just a uncorapative butt.... I have had those as well... take forever! to get up to 200. I know you turn out great que, so don't let 1 piece of meat change your style. [​IMG]
  3. dougmays

    dougmays Limited Mod Group Lead

    haha i feel like it's been the last few bbq's i've done...i'll just blame it on the meat :)
  4. fpnmf

    fpnmf Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    I run mine at 245-250 has no effect on the quality of the smoked item for me.

    That was my breakfast caserole btw
  5. dougmays

    dougmays Limited Mod Group Lead

    ah crap! sorry Craig...i'm terrible at pairing usernames to names.

    you gonna join us again this year??

    yea i think i'm gonna start trying out 245-250 for my pork butts for now on
  6. jckdanls 07

    jckdanls 07 Master of the Pit Group Lead OTBS Member

    yup.. I run em a little hotter nowadays as well... Craig... you gotta come to the gathering... I want some more of your B'fast casserole and your sausage... good stuff...

    As for you Doug... I would blame it on the meats as well... cuz I've tasted your cooking and you do know how... I've had this problem as well..

    "Just because it's small... doesn't mean it doesn't have stamina" ... LOL...
  7. rdknb

    rdknb Master of the Pit OTBS Member SMF Premier Member

    I agree nothing high heat about 250. 
  8. michael ark

    michael ark Master of the Pit

    Last 2 butts I did were farmland . I had the longest stall ever on both of them . I have alway bought my butts at sam's but these were gave to me. I ended up with the pit at 300f started at 225f . I put it on at 1and it was done at 9 at 7:45 is when I put the heat to it. I have started keeping track of what kind of butts give me alonger stall.
  9. I wouldn't worry about it, just sounds like a stubborn cut. The smallest shoulder I have ever cooked on my smoker was just shy of 8 lbs and it took nearly 18 hours to hit 200*..... that was the longest a shoulder has ever taken for me. On the flip side the biggest butt I have ever cooked that was around 12.5 lbs and it finished in 13 hours.... so honestly I wouldn't worry about it. If you had more time to wait it out your shoulder probably would have been just as good as they normally are. We all know there are no shortcuts in bbq, but that is what makes the juice worth the squeeze! 
  10. fpnmf

    fpnmf Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    We had a great time there..Those scouts loved finishing off the casserole..hahahahahaha...

    Not sure about vacation destination this year yet. 

  11. oldschoolbbq

    oldschoolbbq Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    Don't forget to be "Patient", it ain't gonna be ready until it's a watched pot never boils [​IMG]

    LOL !

Share This Page