Japanese A5 Wagyu NY - Again!

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Total agree Courtney, the texture and rendering are perfect in the 140-142º range. Absolutely a perfect dinner, expertly prepared. POINTS!

Matt
 
Leftovers……I seared the third steak yesturday to about INT 100 then cooled it and vac sealed for leftovers…..last nights dinner started with it coming up to room temp then into a Hex with some beef tallow about 1/8 inch, maybe a bit more to simulate the natural tallow sear to finish off the sear and bring it back up to temp. Then a butter and herb bath……
IMG_1155.jpeg

Just to help understand why these sear so good is the fat content and the tallow in the pan….ie it sits in about 350-370 degree oil and effectively shallow fry’s them…… the added tallow the second day simulate the natural developed oil of a fresh sear…..see the bubbling hot oil in action after I poured the pan oil over for the rest
IMG_1157.jpeg

Pulled it at 142 same as the previous day cook….

We changed it up with some tempura veggies and and Asian cucumber salad…… man I’m such a happy and content beef man at the moment. My taste buds are still in heaven……
IMG_1158.jpeg

I rich I could explain the emotions this caused when eating it…..not much talking by the fam…..
IMG_1159.jpeg


And the last set of crème brûlée…..this just finished it off right!
IMG_1160.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Total agree Courtney, the texture and rendering are perfect in the 140-142º range. Absolutely a perfect dinner, expertly prepared. POINTS!

Matt
Much appreciated Matt,

Before I did this the first time I watched many chefs cooking demos and one from a MStar chef that cooks them every night. He suggested the medium cook and a pickled element, he was spot on all the way! The pickled element resets the taste buds so each bite is like the first bit….. I will be honest that eating 4/5 oz of this stuff nearly brings tears to my eyes!!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: schlotz
Civil, don't get me wrong . Loved the meal the first time around.
But for me I like a little less pink is how I like them. I know too well done for some but I love this set better.
And just look at this

1740931747333.png


Great meal both days and love the sides also.

David

ps: and a beautiful cracking Creme Brulee, just saying.
 
Last edited:
Civil, don't get me wrong . Loved the meal the first time around.
But for me I like a little less pink is how I like them. I know too well done for some but I love this set better.
And just look at this

View attachment 714109

Great meal both days and love the sides also.

David

ps: and a beautiful cracking Creme Brulee, just saying.
Thanks David and my wife liked a medium temp, ie just a hint of pink so I’ve eaten many of them and if done right they can be very tasty too!!!

Oh yes seeing bubbling tallow and butter over a seared steak is a beautiful sight for sure!!!!

I have a fine needle torch that is perfect for the sugar work….it has a bamboo skewer size pure blue flame point that allows for precision torching. A large torch flame can kill the custard in a blink of an eye!
Awesome cook !
Thanks chop!!
Fantastic!
Many thanks ronf!
 
  • Like
Reactions: DRKsmoking
Well tonight’s meal is the end of the A5 in the house…..the boy was on dinner duty……so he went into scratch mode and he developed a broth then used these noodles….
IMG_1165.jpeg

Once the noodles were done he portioned them in the bowls then dropped the leftover A5 slices in the broth and the most amazing thing happed…..as the fat rendered out it mixed in and thickened the broth into a gravy. I have NEVER seen such a thing….the result was a bowl of heaven!!!!!! The A5 flavor was imparted into the gravy and made it truly special!!!!
IMG_1163.jpeg

This is bar none the best bowl of beef noodle soup I have had in my life!!!!!
IMG_1164.jpeg

Until next time…..as we are now in the cooling off mode to come back to reality…..ie a $1.50 hot dog & drink combo may be on the menu…..lol.
 
Well I just am speechless. That's 3 meals that are off the charts, but I too, am priced out of the A5 market. Maybe one day, though...
 
Well I think I’ve made a self commitment to experience this wonderful beef on a semi annual occasion!!!

This meal was the second roast from the set we bought for my sons b-day and our anniversary

https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/japanese-a5-wagyu-new-york-butter-cream-poached-lobster-and-idaho-russet-fries-with-herbed-olive-oil-drizzle……-lots-o-pics.328743/

I feasted the steaks the same way….ie thick cut and instead of loser salt I used Himalayan pink salt. Many suggest it as its salinity matched the A5 better
View attachment 713996
The dry brined for 36 hours in the fridge…
View attachment 713995
Getting every thing prepped, letting A5 come up to room temp and the fry’s are about ready to par fry!
View attachment 713997
The hexclad ready to sear….started with a dry pan…..no nerves thing this time….confident it will sear perfection!!!!
View attachment 713998
Got both sides now the first flat….just look at the rendered fat!
View attachment 713999
Flip one! Oh my!!!!
View attachment 714000
Another flip….just getting it perfect on the sear and internal temp…I was using my thermopen to keep it under the desired INT
View attachment 714001
This time I did a butter tallow herb bath as well…..
View attachment 714002
Bingo INT 142 all really to rest….my boy did a butter poached onion slice to go with them……
View attachment 714003
View attachment 714004

All done resting ready to slice……what a sight….I’m in awe of the chef’s that get to cook A5 on a daily basis….what a treat these are just a enjoyable and satisfying cooking experience!!!!
View attachment 714005
The slicing! A perfect medium for A5. You can’t see any internal fat and the reason to the medium INT!
View attachment 714006
And for the plating…..some Idaho russet fry’s butter poached onion and some picked cucumber salad that me wife made up…..
View attachment 714007
The money shot!!!!
View attachment 714008
Many chefs say pickled sides help balance the richness of the A5 and I can say this with 100% agree with this….it helps reset the palate so each bit of the A5 is as the first bit!!!

Oh and now the real $$$ desert item that makes the A5 seem cheap……..
View attachment 714009
Bam bam the wife nailed these l, I did the sugar work!
View attachment 714010
Thanks for joining me again on the A5 journey!
for the love of god...im drooling everything looks absolutely delicious :emoji_astonished:
 
Well I think I’ve made a self commitment to experience this wonderful beef on a semi annual occasion!!!

This meal was the second roast from the set we bought for my sons b-day and our anniversary

https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/japanese-a5-wagyu-new-york-butter-cream-poached-lobster-and-idaho-russet-fries-with-herbed-olive-oil-drizzle……-lots-o-pics.328743/

I feasted the steaks the same way….ie thick cut and instead of loser salt I used Himalayan pink salt. Many suggest it as its salinity matched the A5 better
View attachment 713996
The dry brined for 36 hours in the fridge…
View attachment 713995
Getting every thing prepped, letting A5 come up to room temp and the fry’s are about ready to par fry!
View attachment 713997
The hexclad ready to sear….started with a dry pan…..no nerves thing this time….confident it will sear perfection!!!!
View attachment 713998
Got both sides now the first flat….just look at the rendered fat!
View attachment 713999
Flip one! Oh my!!!!
View attachment 714000
Another flip….just getting it perfect on the sear and internal temp…I was using my thermopen to keep it under the desired INT
View attachment 714001
This time I did a butter tallow herb bath as well…..
View attachment 714002
Bingo INT 142 all really to rest….my boy did a butter poached onion slice to go with them……
View attachment 714003
View attachment 714004

All done resting ready to slice……what a sight….I’m in awe of the chef’s that get to cook A5 on a daily basis….what a treat these are just a enjoyable and satisfying cooking experience!!!!
View attachment 714005
The slicing! A perfect medium for A5. You can’t see any internal fat and the reason to the medium INT!
View attachment 714006
And for the plating…..some Idaho russet fry’s butter poached onion and some picked cucumber salad that me wife made up…..
View attachment 714007
The money shot!!!!
View attachment 714008
Many chefs say pickled sides help balance the richness of the A5 and I can say this with 100% agree with this….it helps reset the palate so each bit of the A5 is as the first bit!!!

Oh and now the real $$$ desert item that makes the A5 seem cheap……..
View attachment 714009
Bam bam the wife nailed these l, I did the sugar work!
View attachment 714010
Thanks for joining me again on the A5 journey!
Wow! Thank you. Anniversary coming up.. Since there's no real news this morning, I went on a google-fest to learn more.
I have no clue as to the authenticity of these guys,
 
That just sounds and looks amazing Civil!
I've never tried Wagyu much less an A5. But when you get 3 meals of that quality?

Keith
 
Well I think I’ve made a self commitment to experience this wonderful beef on a semi annual occasion!!!

This meal was the second roast from the set we bought for my sons b-day and our anniversary

https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/japanese-a5-wagyu-new-york-butter-cream-poached-lobster-and-idaho-russet-fries-with-herbed-olive-oil-drizzle……-lots-o-pics.328743/

I feasted the steaks the same way….ie thick cut and instead of loser salt I used Himalayan pink salt. Many suggest it as its salinity matched the A5 better
View attachment 713996
The dry brined for 36 hours in the fridge…
View attachment 713995
Getting every thing prepped, letting A5 come up to room temp and the fry’s are about ready to par fry!
View attachment 713997
The hexclad ready to sear….started with a dry pan…..no nerves thing this time….confident it will sear perfection!!!!
View attachment 713998
Got both sides now the first flat….just look at the rendered fat!
View attachment 713999
Flip one! Oh my!!!!
View attachment 714000
Another flip….just getting it perfect on the sear and internal temp…I was using my thermopen to keep it under the desired INT
View attachment 714001
This time I did a butter tallow herb bath as well…..
View attachment 714002
Bingo INT 142 all really to rest….my boy did a butter poached onion slice to go with them……
View attachment 714003
View attachment 714004

All done resting ready to slice……what a sight….I’m in awe of the chef’s that get to cook A5 on a daily basis….what a treat these are just a enjoyable and satisfying cooking experience!!!!
View attachment 714005
The slicing! A perfect medium for A5. You can’t see any internal fat and the reason to the medium INT!
View attachment 714006
And for the plating…..some Idaho russet fry’s butter poached onion and some picked cucumber salad that me wife made up…..
View attachment 714007
The money shot!!!!
View attachment 714008
Many chefs say pickled sides help balance the richness of the A5 and I can say this with 100% agree with this….it helps reset the palate so each bit of the A5 is as the first bit!!!

Oh and now the real $$$ desert item that makes the A5 seem cheap……..
View attachment 714009
Bam bam the wife nailed these l, I did the sugar work!
View attachment 714010
Thanks for joining me again on the A5 journey!
quick question... is A5 A5 everywhere? To clarify, I've never seen in store. they have it at wild fork or whatever its called if i want to do 1.5hrs of Miami traffic. just wondered how strictly its graded for a Benjamin a bone.
 
Last edited:
Well I just am speechless. That's 3 meals that are off the charts, but I too, am priced out of the A5 market. Maybe one day, though...
Many thanks GS! I probably would have never shelled out the coin if it wasn't for the boy stating that is all he wanted for his birthday......And it was all he did get....
for the love of god...im drooling everything looks absolutely delicious :emoji_astonished:
Much appreciated slav! ps, I'm still drooling!
That just sounds and looks amazing Civil!
I've never tried Wagyu much less an A5. But when you get 3 meals of that quality?

Keith
Thanks Keith and yea when you "count" the plate per cost it ends up being reasonable. Again 3-5 oz serving is a full serving size! I mean if we went to the local steak house and got fillets or NYs for a family of for we are walking out with a 150 bill hit......
 
For those new to wagyu consumption, here is a quick overview you should become familar with. The wagyu lable in the states can repesent a large range of graded meat and is rated in the "F" number sequence ranging from F1 (50% crossbred) to F5 (fullblood, which can trace it's lineage back to Japan). The Japanese 'A' rateing system is based upon the marbling at the 13th rib.

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: civilsmoker
Wow! Thank you. Anniversary coming up.. Since there's no real news this morning, I went on a google-fest to learn more.
I have no clue as to the authenticity of these guys,

Thanks, and you are welcome! The prep those guys did looks tasty and the thin slice is how many prepare it. If you notice their thin cut was well done vs they did the steak cook to rare. I am dry brine then pan sear prep all the way, (I have had the thin cut and the pan fry and slice is better IMO). The MStar chef, I watched did the thin slice and for those that wanted a special cook a pan seared whole rib eye but he cut out the large fat after. If you thin trim the NY edge fat (as I did above) 95% of the seared NY is consumable. The crust on a thick cut is easy to do and it's like beef bacon. Oh, and due to the insulation properties of the fat it takes a lot of searing to get it to medium, just keep rotating to get all the edges crispy.
quick question... is A5 A5 everywhere? To clarify, I've never seen in store. they have it at wild fork or whatever its called if i want to do 1.5hrs of Miami traffic. just wondered how strictly its graded for a Benjamin a bone.
Not all Japanese A5 grade is equal. I have seen it up to 450/lb vs the 75/lb we paid for. Second, I think the NY is the best cut for a DYI because its mostly marbled tissue vs a large fat section like a rib eye. The absolute best is the fillet but it comes at a $$$. If I ever find a money tree, I will spring for some fillets for home cook.....as of now its a bucket list....
 
For those new to wagyu consumption, here is a quick overview you should become familar with. The wagyu lable in the states can repesent a large range of graded meat and is rated in the "F" number sequence ranging from F1 (50% crossbred) to F5 (fullblood, which can trace it's lineage back to Japan). The Japanese 'A' rateing system is based upon the marbling at the 13th rib.

Thanks for sharing schotz, a little research is best because you want be sure you know what you are getting. Ours came with a 100% certification!
 
  • Like
Reactions: schlotz
While even American Wagyu - F5 is still very expensive, we are fortunate our daughter & husband are in the "fullblood" business of raising and selling wagyu. We don't ask for freebies because it's their livelihood but on occasion, we purchase a few cuts to enjoy. Love your approach to the strips!
 
  • Like
Reactions: civilsmoker
Thanks, and you are welcome! The prep those guys did looks tasty and the thin slice is how many prepare it. If you notice their thin cut was well done vs they did the steak cook to rare. I am dry brine then pan sear prep all the way, (I have had the thin cut and the pan fry and slice is better IMO). The MStar chef, I watched did the thin slice and for those that wanted a special cook a pan seared whole rib eye but he cut out the large fat after. If you thin trim the NY edge fat (as I did above) 95% of the seared NY is consumable. The crust on a thick cut is easy to do and it's like beef bacon. Oh, and due to the insulation properties of the fat it takes a lot of searing to get it to medium, just keep rotating to get all the edges crispy.

Not all Japanese A5 grade is equal. I have seen it up to 450/lb vs the 75/lb we paid for. Second, I think the NY is the best cut for a DYI because its mostly marbled tissue vs a large fat section like a rib eye. The absolute best is the fillet but it comes at a $$$. If I ever find a money tree, I will spring for some fillets for home cook.....as of now its a bucket list....
thank you... might not be THIS anniversary :emoji_laughing: :emoji_laughing:
 
  • Like
Reactions: civilsmoker
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky