Japanese A5 Wagyu NY - Again!

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

civilsmoker

Smoking Guru
Original poster
OTBS Member
★ Lifetime Premier ★
Jan 27, 2015
7,000
9,860
Idaho
Well I think I’ve made a self commitment to experience this wonderful beef on a semi annual occasion!!!

This meal was the second roast from the set we bought for my sons b-day and our anniversary

https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/threads/japanese-a5-wagyu-new-york-butter-cream-poached-lobster-and-idaho-russet-fries-with-herbed-olive-oil-drizzle……-lots-o-pics.328743/

I feasted the steaks the same way….ie thick cut and instead of loser salt I used Himalayan pink salt. Many suggest it as its salinity matched the A5 better
IMG_1127.jpeg

The dry brined for 36 hours in the fridge…
IMG_1128.jpeg

Getting every thing prepped, letting A5 come up to room temp and the fry’s are about ready to par fry!
IMG_1135.jpeg

The hexclad ready to sear….started with a dry pan…..no nerves thing this time….confident it will sear perfection!!!!
IMG_1136.jpeg

Got both sides now the first flat….just look at the rendered fat!
IMG_1139.jpeg

Flip one! Oh my!!!!
IMG_1140.jpeg

Another flip….just getting it perfect on the sear and internal temp…I was using my thermopen to keep it under the desired INT
IMG_1141.jpeg

This time I did a butter tallow herb bath as well…..
IMG_1142.jpeg

Bingo INT 142 all really to rest….my boy did a butter poached onion slice to go with them……
IMG_1143.jpeg

IMG_1144.jpeg


All done resting ready to slice……what a sight….I’m in awe of the chef’s that get to cook A5 on a daily basis….what a treat these are just a enjoyable and satisfying cooking experience!!!!
IMG_1146.jpeg

The slicing! A perfect medium for A5. You can’t see any internal fat and the reason to the medium INT!
IMG_1147.jpeg

And for the plating…..some Idaho russet fry’s butter poached onion and some picked cucumber salad that me wife made up…..
IMG_1150.jpeg

The money shot!!!!
IMG_1149.jpeg

Many chefs say pickled sides help balance the richness of the A5 and I can say this with 100% agree with this….it helps reset the palate so each bit of the A5 is as the first bit!!!

Oh and now the real $$$ desert item that makes the A5 seem cheap……..
IMG_1151.jpeg

Bam bam the wife nailed these l, I did the sugar work!
IMG_1152.jpeg

Thanks for joining me again on the A5 journey!
 
SON OF A .... WOW that looks great! I have yet to indulge in this culinary delight. But looking at you product there, man, killing me!
 
  • Like
Reactions: mneeley490
Beeeeeeautiful meal Cortney, You nailed it once again.

POINT for sure
Chris
 
Damn Civil!! What an Amazing looking meal! I bet that meat just melted in your mouth! Nice job!
 
Thought they would be overcooked at that temp but doesn’t look like it. Looks great!
 
You nailed it again !!! Looks beyond perfect. :emoji_thumbsup:
Much appreciated Jax!
Great looking meal
Thanks Jim!
SON OF A .... WOW that looks great! I have yet to indulge in this culinary delight. But looking at you product there, man, killing me!
Many thanks Sandy! I’m not sure I would have ever done it but after having a A5 fillet at a function it pushed me over the line to do it at home!
Beeeeeeautiful meal Cortney, You nailed it once again.

POINT for sure
Chris
Thanks Chris! It’s a really fun meal to do for sure!
 
  • Like
Reactions: sandyut
Damn Civil!! What an Amazing looking meal! I bet that meat just melted in your mouth! Nice job!
Many thanks redi! Yes it’s like meat fudge….thats be best description I can find!
Thought they would be overcooked at that temp but doesn’t look like it. Looks great!
Thanks gator and 145-150 is the sweet spot for A5 as it needs enough internal heat to render the fat…it’s also a beautiful texture as well
That is amazing!!!
Thanks b-doc!
Simply beautiful. The whole plate is amazing. Very nicely done.
Many thanks bigf! Left over tonight!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Redicans
I think you have inspired me to do this for my 20th anniversary this year coming up in few months. I did not realize costco sold A5. Good to know. It looks like a fabulous meal. Fresh cut fries are the bomb too.
 
I saw the 142 temp and thought someone had gone off the rails but I was wrong. Looks great and probably tastes even better
 
Civil, I'm eating my own dinner right now, and looking at yours makes me want to throw mine in the trash.
Well done, sir!
 
I think you have inspired me to do this for my 20th anniversary this year coming up in few months. I did not realize costco sold A5. Good to know. It looks like a fabulous meal. Fresh cut fries are the bomb too.
Oh it’s a great way to celebrate! Though do know you want eat a whole steak at one sitting….the 3 steaks (just under 3 lbs) will end up doing 10 plates.
I saw the 142 temp and thought someone had gone off the rails but I was wrong. Looks great and probably tastes even better
Thanks dons, and for a INT of 145-150 is the sweet spot for A5 as that is needed to render the internal fat. Otherwise it’s just too rich and not the right texture, ie at a 130 int it can be a little chewy
Civil, I'm eating my own dinner right now, and looking at yours makes me want to throw mine in the trash.
Well done, sir!
Thanks mneeley and sorry for messing with your dinner! If it’s any consolation I love good old box mac & cheese too!
Man that's just fine dining at its best!
Thanks jcam! It’s not something you could do every day but it sure makes your day when you do!
 
  • Like
Reactions: jcam222
Wow Civil, that entire meal looks downright perfect. Nicely done 👍
Thanks JL!
I could not do A5 due to the price here but what you cooked up looks damn good.
Thanks Chris! I would expect your Costco price to be the same as my Costco price. Just some perspective we will be in 10 plates/servings for $300 (the eggs prices for desert isn’t cheep either) so 30 a plate, but to take the fam out at the big town place for A5 would have been about $750 for just a table of four. This A5 was 75/lb and I’ve had 5 oz of 400/lb fillet and honestly it was only a hair line better…..ie fillet vs NY.
Very nice plate and presentation there Civil, Great sear on those .
I'm all in on the dessert also.

David
Much appreciated David! I’ve only cooked 6 A5 steaks now but they are just fun to cook! Oh and crème brûlée is about my favorite desert!
 
  • Like
Reactions: DRKsmoking
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky