Hi there and welcome!
Great work on the chicken! Yeah the store bought rotisserie always looks good BUT is always a let down. These smoked chickens cant be beat!
BTW, if you end up with tough/rubbery skin that is not any fault of your own. Poultry skin just doesn't like to be edible cooked at lower temps. At 325F smoker temp it will be edible BUT you have an MES so 275F is your max if it can hit that.
One solution is to have a hot gas grill ready and to smoke your chicken to like an Internal Temp (IT) of like 140F and then finish it skin side down on the grill... or just cook skinless chicken lol.
Also having poultry sit vertically in the MES helps the skin cook better but may not solve the problem alone.
Finally, the MES is notorious for having the smoker temp probe and meat probe just be plain wrong. When you get a chance you may want to look into a dual probe (or more probes) wireless digital thermometer. A number of brands out there will work.
Also the A-Maze-N Pellet Smoker (
AMNPS) tray will give you 12 hours of perfect Thin Blue Smoke (TBS) without having to fool with it.
These are 2 items almost all of us MES owners get first to make life easy and continue putting together food that cant be beat! :)
[EDIT] Check this brand new thread for discount on a wireless dual probe thermometer that will probably work and for $28 with the coupon code, that is a steal!
https://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t...ess-thermometer-irf-2sa-with-2-probes.289553/
In any case, great work, keep on smoking, and I look forward to the next post!!! :)