• Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.

Seasoning advice needed for first chuck

SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

sandyut

Smoking Guru
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Feb 18, 2015
5,143
4,232
We recently tried a new bbq place here in Memphis
Memphis you say? I have fam there. whats the name and how was it? so far my fav is the germantown commissary. what is/are your fav places for grabbin Q in the area?
 

WaterRat

Master of the Pit
Feb 14, 2018
1,192
914
Thanks for all this advice everyone! Not sure what I’m going to do with the beef yet, but I’m leaning towards making a French dip type sandwich. Maybe making up a horseradish sauce, Au jus, and putting the meat on some onion rolls or French bread with melted provolone and caramelized onions.

Yumm, I've done that several times with a chucky. If you need a horseradish sauce here is my go to: https://www.chowhound.com/recipes/horseradish-cream-sauce-28403 I use an electric hand mixer, I've tried doing it with a whisk and it takes forever.
 

bgaviator

Smoking Fanatic
Thread starter
May 9, 2010
418
426
Memphis you say? I have fam there. whats the name and how was it? so far my fav is the germantown commissary. what is/are your fav places for grabbin Q in the area?
That place with the beef ribs was called One and Only. They have several locations around Memphis. It was outstanding. We normally frequent Memphis BBQ Company, but One and Only might have me switching it up more. Central BBQ is outstanding as well, but I’m just never in that part of town to have them often. Not a fan of Germantown Commissary, but I think I got them on an off day. Plus I went there at an off time between lunch and dinner so I’m not sure if that affected my experience. A ton of people like the Commissary though so maybe I’ll give them another try someday.
 

bgaviator

Smoking Fanatic
Thread starter
May 9, 2010
418
426
Went to the BBQ Supply Shop today and told the guy I was planning on making a chuck roast. He gave me some rub suggestions as well. I ended up picking up Malcom Reed’s AP Rub. The guy at the store said that would be good, but that it’s a little heavy on the garlic...but hey, I like garlic. Figured I’d give it a shot. Doesn’t look like there’s a ton of black pepper in the AP Rub, so I might grind some more over the top. I like Malcom’s videos, so I like supporting his business. I appreciate all the suggestions everyone. They all sound fantastic and sounds like no shortage of ways to season these things. I picked up some Oak wood for this cook too as I’ve always heard oak is good with beef. Never cooked with oak before though.
 

sandyut

Smoking Guru
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Feb 18, 2015
5,143
4,232
Memphis BBQ looks pretty good. might need to check it out. thanks!
 

Bearcarver

Gone but not forgotten RIP
OTBS Member
Group Lead
Sep 12, 2009
45,279
18,184
There is if your a Vampire...

Chris


Me & Mrs Bear must be Vampires, because I like Garlic Powder, but we can't handle actual garlic. When we were Kids, my brother used to pull wild garlic out of the yard, while we were playing football. Then he'd wipe the mud off & eat it.
I can only handle a little.
We slept in the same room when we were kids, so I guess his smell kept me safe at night, from Dracula.

Bear
 

xray

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
Mar 11, 2015
4,747
3,269
I’m not a werewolf either because I like silver bullets!
 

Hawging It

Master of the Pit
OTBS Member
Jan 1, 2019
2,827
1,713
That place with the beef ribs was called One and Only. They have several locations around Memphis. It was outstanding. We normally frequent Memphis BBQ Company, but One and Only might have me switching it up more. Central BBQ is outstanding as well, but I’m just never in that part of town to have them often. Not a fan of Germantown Commissary, but I think I got them on an off day. Plus I went there at an off time between lunch and dinner so I’m not sure if that affected my experience. A ton of people like the Commissary though so maybe I’ll give them another try someday.
A couple of years ago I worked in Memphis for several months. I tried em all LOL! In my view Blues City Cafe right across the street from BB Kings on Beale is by far the best in Memphis for pork ribs. The Commissary in Germantown by the railroad tracks is second. Went back a year ago on R & R with the wife and went to both again. Still our 2 favs. Just our opinion. The Historic Rendezvous is not what it used to be. Tourist joint and fairly weak ribs if you ask us.
 

Bearcarver

Gone but not forgotten RIP
OTBS Member
Group Lead
Sep 12, 2009
45,279
18,184
I’m not a werewolf either because I like silver bullets!


I like Silver Bullets too, ever since "The Lone Stripper" gave Richie C. a Silver Bullet, on a "Happy Days" episode.

Bear
 

jcam222

Epic Pitmaster
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Jun 13, 2017
11,505
13,471
Smoked Beef doesn't need much help. You don't want to cover up the Great Beef Flavor.
Here's a Step by Step on how I do Chuckies, including the small amount of Seasoning:
Smoked Pulled Beef Chucky

Bear
I will second this. I like using some flavor combos in ribs and often for beef incorporate some coffee and cocoa. That said I just did some beef ribs and went pretty basic. I hit them first with just a light dusting of Accent and then SPOG in a 2/2/1/1 ratio. I used granulated garlic and onion. I did hit them with a very light dusting of dark chili powder and I stress light. Anyway it made for a very nice crunchy tasty bark. I’ll be using that approach on more of my beef cooks.
 

bgaviator

Smoking Fanatic
Thread starter
May 9, 2010
418
426
A couple of years ago I worked in Memphis for several months. I tried em all LOL! In my view Blues City Cafe right across the street from BB Kings on Beale is by far the best in Memphis for pork ribs. The Commissary in Germantown by the railroad tracks is second. Went back a year ago on R & R with the wife and went to both again. Still our 2 favs. Just our opinion. The Historic Rendezvous is not what it used to be. Tourist joint and fairly weak ribs if you ask us.
Haven’t tried Blues City Cafe yet. The only place I’ve eaten at on Beale is BB King’s. They have great food, just too loud for me with the live music. I’ll have to give Blues City a try, the pics look good.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Top Bottom
Clicky