Scared of Brisket

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

whistlepig

Smoking Fanatic
Original poster
Dec 23, 2011
669
265
Preble County, OH
Yep. I am the afraid of brisket guy. I am the one that has been escorted out of the meat departments for fondling their briskets without buying one. We'll see how this brisket turns out tomorrow. Smoked prime rib is my favorite. I have done three prime ribs in the my smoker with excellent results. I'm going to give brisket a try out tomorrow. Brisket is going to have to go along way to match my prime rib.           
 
I'm kind of the opposite, I wasn't scared to try a brisket but I am a prime rib, a lot more money to lose if I mess it up but I'm going to have to bite the bullet and try it soon. I'm sure you have done your homework on brisket and I'm confident from reading your other posts it will come out just fine. Remember the Q-View!!!
 
I'm kind of the opposite, I wasn't scared to try a brisket but I am a prime rib, a lot more money to lose if I mess it up but I'm going to have to bite the bullet and try it soon. I'm sure you have done your homework on brisket and I'm confident from reading your other posts it will come out just fine. Remember the Q-View!!!
I understand. A five pound prime rib for me takes about four hours to smoke to medium rare. From what I have read a five pound brisket takes about ten hours. A ten hour smoke is a lot more serious than a four hour smoke. Ten hours tending a smoker is something to be considered. Is brisket really worth it? 
 
If you do burnt ends it is well worth it just for one bite. They are fabulous! 
 
Neither cut should be reason to fear.  Prime or Brisket if temp is controlled steady and you finish to correct internal temp should yeild consistant results.  Smile they are both great!
 
It's actually real simple. Cook the whole brisket til it is done, around 190* then separate the point from the flat. You can do this with a butter knife, just find the fat line inbetween them and cut a little then just lift the point off. Foil the flat and put it up to rest. Then cube the point in about 1 - 1 1/2 inch cubes, toss them in your favorite BBQ sauce mixed with your favorite rub and then place them back on the smoker for another hour or two. Some people put them in a foil pan some just put them right on the rack until the sauce caramelizes. The last time I did them I used a spicy chipotle sauce mixed with some brown sugar and they were great. I like heat and the sauces heat with the sweet brown sugar was incredible. What really got me though was the tenderness, they were melt in your mouth almost like jello, more tender than any filet or prime rib I ever had. I was amazed by that.
 
Burnt ends...yummy!  I'll be making some of those Sunday!  I think alot of people consider the brisket as the 'Holy Grail' of BBQ.  And I guess to an extent, it is.  It is large and for a single piece of meat, it is expensive.   Just don't fear it, the brisket can smell fear.  Just rub it, smoke it, eat it.  As far as temps, I have smoked 'em at 225, 250 and up to 275.  All with similiar results.  The biggest factor is consistent temps.  Whatever temp you choose to run, try to keep it steady through the whole cook, don't open the lid at all for the first 3-4 hours!  If your lookin', you ain't cookin'!  At comps, I start the briskets early at 225, after they have been foiled at 165 IT, it is about time for me to put my ribs on and within an hour or so , get the yardbird on.  So at this point I ease my pit temp up to 250.  The briskets have been foiled with juice and are steaming their way to tenderness.  If using a temp probe, make sure it is in the middle of the flat, dead center from the side.  Probing in the point will give you funky readings, too much fat content.  A couple of times I have tracked temps through a cook on both the point and flat, with the point being 10 degrees or more higher than the flat.  When the flat is done, the point is done.  I have had success with cooking to 205 IT.  I have never tried pulling at 190 IT, but  I know when they hit 190, it doesn't take much longer to get over 200.  I might have to try it one day.  Good luck on your brisket, if you need help, you're at the right place. 
 
Thanks for the replies and good advice on the burnt ends. It's been in the smoker for 5 hours now. It's stalled at 151 degrees for over an hour and a half now. Smoker temp is a steady 210 degrees. Does this stall sound too long? It's a five pound brisket.
 
 
Thanks for the replies and good advice on the burnt ends. It's been in the smoker for 5 hours now. It's stalled at 151 degrees for over an hour and a half now. Smoker temp is a steady 210 degrees. Does this stall sound too long? It's a five pound brisket.
 
The last 2 I've done stalled for almost 3 hours @ around 163 degrees. These were heavier ones so it might be different. How long has it been in the smoker?
 
It's been in the smoker for six hours now. It went to 151 degrees in 4 hours. Temp just went up two degrees to 153. I think (I hope) the stall is over. This is only a 5 pound brisket. I can understand why brisket is considered the one of the ultimate smokes. I can't figure out what this piece of meat is going to do next.
 
 
I usually foil mine at around 150 it will help power through the stall. Mmm burnt ends, time for a brisket. Don't be askert of no brisket, lots of good info on here that will help make it successful. Smoke on!
 
I'm going to ride it out and foil at 165 degrees. I've smoked 10# turkeys and 5# roasts and they were done in 5 hours. Brisket seems to be a beast of it's own.
 
 
Where you at now?  Sounds like everything is going smoothly.
At 158 degrees now. I just bumped the smoker temp up to 225 degrees. If I ever have another house built I will ask the contractor if he can insulate it with brisket. I have never seen a substance more resistant to a temperature change.
 
It's been in the smoker for six hours now. It went to 151 degrees in 4 hours. Temp just went up two degrees to 153. I think (I hope) the stall is over. This is only a 5 pound brisket. I can understand why brisket is considered the one of the ultimate smokes. I can't figure out what this piece of meat is going to do next.
 
Ha. Thats the whole thing that makes the Brisky " Tricky." ...We NEVER know what they're gonna' do. I just put two 5 pounders in the pit about 30 minutes ago myself, and I'm totally prepared to wait from 12 to maybe 16, 17 hours. No one really ever knows.........'specially those of us using charcoal in  an offset.

Good luck, and enjoy the hours just-a-watchin' the smoke roll..............
 
This brisket is going to fail. After 10.5 hours on a 5 pound brisket the internal temp is just 160 degrees smoking at 210 degrees. Brisket is just too much hassle. It will be a very long time before I try brisket again.
 
 
This brisket is going to fail. After 10.5 hours on a 5 pound brisket the internal temp is just 160 degrees smoking at 210 degrees. Brisket is just too much hassle. It will be a very long time before I try brisket again.
 
You might want to try doing a full packer next time.... I know it sounds crazy, but the full packers are more forgiving than the flats. Also as always check the probes for accuracy before the smoke, and if needed move the probe to another part of the brisket... sometimes you get a bad reading and have to move the probe. Other than that you are doing everything right, low, slow, and patient - I have had some full packers finish as early as 12 hrs. while others take 18 hrs.
 
I'm kind of the opposite, I wasn't scared to try a brisket but I am a prime rib, a lot more money to lose if I mess it up but I'm going to have to bite the bullet and try it soon. I'm sure you have done your homework on brisket and I'm confident from reading your other posts it will come out just fine. Remember the Q-View!!!
I have to agree! I finally bit the bullet a few weeks ago and did a brisket (and yes I was terrified but ruining a great tasting and not to mention expensive cut like a prime rib scares me more than the brisket! 

Goodluck and I'm sure you'll do fine, after all you've mastered Prime Rib!
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky