Lump charcoal vs Briquettes

Discussion in 'Grilling Tips' started by smoking chief, Apr 27, 2014.

  1. Is there a difference between the two as far as flavor?
  2. bluewhisper

    bluewhisper Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    Lump lights cleaner. Briquettes can have ingredients like coal that give a bad flavor as they light. But, pound for pound, briquettes have more long-lasting heat.
  3. timberjet

    timberjet Master of the Pit

    There is. Lump charcoal is hardwood so you are getting some smoke flavor from it itself. I don't like to use it much as it is quite a bit more expensive and burns faster and hotter. I am a kingsford kind of guy.
  4. noboundaries

    noboundaries Smoking Guru OTBS Member SMF Premier Member

    For grilling I use Kingsford Blue Bag.

    For smoking I mix KBB briquette and Lazarri lump, but I have my reasons for doing so.

    I find briquettes alone (Kingsford Blue) take longer to get up to temp and get through the white/grey smoke stage than lump, but I like the price, especially around the holidays when it is 22-32 cents a lb.  The KBB also helps keep the fire burning steady longer. 

    Lump alone burns a little too hot for my dry smokes but gets to the TBS stage quickly and maintains a nice, steady temp once burning.  The cheapest lump in my area is Lazarri Mesquite lump, which I can get anytime at 50 cents a pound in a 40 lb bag, and sometimes as little as 15 cents a pound on sale at my local grocer.  The mesquite flavor is only noticeable if there are wood chunks that are not completely carbonized, which I have noticed on a rare occasion.  The Lazarri sparks like the 4th of July though and I don't like that.  It also has pieces that run from tiny to big, and the tiny pieces can fall through the charcoal grates wasting charcoal.

    Here's what I do to get the fire/smoke I want on the WSM smoker and not lose lump through the grates:

         I pile all the used charcoal in the center of the charcoal basket, then put down a single layer of briquettes to fill in the empty spaces on the charcoal grates.  I add my wood, then dump the lump on the foundation of briquettes and used charcoal.  Then I light briquettes in the chimney and spread those on top of the center of the pile.  20 minutes later I find if I take the lid off, dump the white smoke, let it burn for a minute or so with no lid, then put the lid back on, the smoker is usually ready to load meat with smoke turning to light blue right at 30 minutes.  Because I smoke hot n fast most of the time I load my meat just as the smoke is starting to show hints of blue.
  5. bbq1950

    bbq1950 Fire Starter

    I agree with Bluewhisper, briquettes do have other materials compressed into them. But pound for pound Kingsford work the best.
    Just my opinion.
    Enjoy the forum.
    Smoke On !
  6. I go lump for almost everything. I use the same brand every time and learned how to work it. I don't like putting the glues and fillers into my food. Now with that said I do keep a bag of briquettes around for dutch oven cooking so I can have a more evenly spread heat and know my temps better.

Share This Page