What Do You Use Briquettes or Lumpwood Charcoal?

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
I can't speak for wow bbq but our offer of a 15% is still available for all members, just let me know if you are interested and I will pm you a voucher code (it's a marketing thing so I know who's buying what) 

Jeeze Georgie are you related to Wade, I am seeing some resemblance.

Regards

SM
 
Last edited:
Hey Wade, I have just noticed we are still waiting for the comparison, I don't know of what because it's been a month or 6 
Beating_A_Dead_Horse_by_livius.gif


On the subject of heat beads, I only had a few left, so I topped them up with the natural briquettes, and they burned OK. created a lot of dust though, I had to empty the dust pan 3 times!! 
 
Today I tried the Minion method using charcoal, filled basket with said charcoal and just lit at one side (correct me if this is wrong)

With both vents closed and chimney open temp went to 350f and stayed there for approx 3 hours and then coals were just about burnt out.

I know this is too hot to smoke and am at a loss as to how to bring temps down, will try again soon.
 
Hello Georgie.  350 is not too hot to smoke unless you are talking 350c..  But THAT is a WHOLE different story and not for now.  What we need to do is discover why you can not get temps down in your smoker.  NOW!  Here I go sticking my foot in mouth again BUT closing down the exhaust stack is NOT a horrible thing.  I do it and I know Wade does it.  What you MUST NOT do is close it completely.  The next problem is just how much SMOKE are you producing from your smoker?  What colour is the smoke coming from the smoker?  These are things that are experience related.  This is not where we should start.  These we can discuss much later.  You need to be able to control temps in your new smoker.

Here is my thought.  IF you tried the minion method and the lower vents were closed and the temp was STILL 350 and "roaring"; you have an air flow problem.  So here is what I would suggest:  Go buy some cheap charcoal like as in B&Q.  Load the basket and fire it up.  What you think you might use in 6-8 hours.  Light the whole thing.  ALL vents WIDE open.  NO MEAT USED.  Get good white coals going.  Now close down the bottom vents, doors and the stack; leave the stack "cracked" about 1/2 open.  Either pour a little water on the coals or "spritz"  with a spray bottle.  BIG WHITE smoke.  Now close up except for that small exhaust opening and see where the leaks are.  Now if the smoker is "drawing" properly, air would be "sucked" in from the air leaks and then out the fully open exhaust ( fully open in your case ).  So the smoker would be "drawing" air like a chimney and causing the coals to burn hotter and faster.  So the smoker is sort of working properly but you have no control.  If you still don't really see leaks close the exhaust fully.  You must remember what you built that smoker from.  It looks GREAT but a propane tank is very thin.  As you cut that metal it will warp.  You may need many more latches to insure a proper seal.  What you should see is billowing white smoke out of the 1/2 open exhaust and the heat should start dropping immediately and the coals got out in a short time.  If a fire MUST "breath" and "eat".  If it can not it will soon die.

These are just my thoughts.  Maybe someone will have a better idea.  Keep Smokin!

Danny
 
  • Like
Reactions: georgie porgie
Hi Georgie - Which smoker are you trying this with?

It sounds as if you have an air control problem (leak) near your fire basket. Can we have some photos?

Cheers

Wade
 
 
Hello Georgie.  350 is not too hot to smoke unless you are talking 350c..  But THAT is a WHOLE different story and not for now.  What we need to do is discover why you can not get temps down in your smoker.  NOW!  Here I go sticking my foot in mouth again BUT closing down the exhaust stack is NOT a horrible thing.  I do it and I know Wade does it.  What you MUST NOT do is close it completely.  The next problem is just how much SMOKE are you producing from your smoker?  What colour is the smoke coming from the smoker?  These are things that are experience related.  This is not where we should start.  These we can discuss much later.  You need to be able to control temps in your new smoker.

Here is my thought.  IF you tried the minion method and the lower vents were closed and the temp was STILL 350 and "roaring"; you have an air flow problem.  So here is what I would suggest:  Go buy some cheap charcoal like as in B&Q.  Load the basket and fire it up.  What you think you might use in 6-8 hours.  Light the whole thing.  ALL vents WIDE open.  NO MEAT USED.  Get good white coals going.  Now close down the bottom vents, doors and the stack; leave the stack "cracked" about 1/2 open.  Either pour a little water on the coals or "spritz"  with a spray bottle.  BIG WHITE smoke.  Now close up except for that small exhaust opening and see where the leaks are.  Now if the smoker is "drawing" properly, air would be "sucked" in from the air leaks and then out the fully open exhaust ( fully open in your case ).  So the smoker would be "drawing" air like a chimney and causing the coals to burn hotter and faster.  So the smoker is sort of working properly but you have no control.  If you still don't really see leaks close the exhaust fully.  You must remember what you built that smoker from.  It looks GREAT but a propane tank is very thin.  As you cut that metal it will warp.  You may need many more latches to insure a proper seal.  What you should see is billowing white smoke out of the 1/2 open exhaust and the heat should start dropping immediately and the coals got out in a short time.  If a fire MUST "breath" and "eat".  If it can not it will soon die.

These are just my thoughts.  Maybe someone will have a better idea.  Keep Smokin!

Danny
Thanks Danny, I am having problems with the air intake on one side, as its a home made one it was impossible to get a full closure


Also there is a small amount of smoke from the top doors even though there is fire rope all way round on all doors, this has just made me more determined to sort things

as I feel we're so close to getting it right.

One thing we have in mind is to make a smaller fire box to the left side connected to the inlet that way the heat shouldn't be as intense.
 
 
Hi Georgie - Which smoker are you trying this with?

It sounds as if you have an air control problem (leak) near your fire basket. Can we have some photos?

Cheers

Wade
Hi Wade, its a home made one (Heath Robinson inspired) and yes we have an air control problem but are thinking of ways to stop it

one being thicker seals on the doors. I've ordered some Heat Mate Resistant Silicone Sealant  to help with this.

 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky