Stuffed Portabella's

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

bigal

Smoking Fanatic
Original poster
OTBS Member
Sep 21, 2006
970
10
Western Kansas
Finally found portabella mushrooms! I've been want'n to stuff these for a long time.

Cleaned out "most" of gills(more room for stuff'n)
Sprayed them w/olive oil
Stuffed w/crab, celery, onion, cheese and mayo
sprinkled on some of Jeffs rub
on the smoker at bout 235.

Plan on smoke'n for 45 min then add cheddar cheese, melt and then ready to eat.

Here's some pix w/end product to come.

Sure hope they taste as good as they sound. First time for us to ever have portabellas. Just did 3 w/6 left to go. I hope the last 3 I will learn enough to get them just how we like them.

Enjoy the pix. http://s194.photobucket.com/albums/z2/lonefarm/
 
IF YOU WANT TO PUT THEM INTO AN ALUM FOIL PAN TO ADD CHEESE THEN TAKE INTO HOUSE.......USE A SPATULA!!! SLICK SOBS!!!

DROPPED ONE IN THE SMOKER, ALL STUFF'N CAME OUT!!!
icon_evil.gif


!@#$% %$##@ !@#$% %$#@@! !@#$% THAT MAKES ME MAD!!!
icon_evil.gif
icon_evil.gif
icon_evil.gif


Well 2 outta 3 aint bad, well see how it goes. !@#$!!!

End product to come shortly. ........!@#$%!!!!!!!!!!!!
icon_evil.gif
 
Try'n a pic on the thread. Close up.





And another




Thanks to IT and WD, IT's knowledge and WD's cry'n
PDT_Armataz_01_22.gif
PDT_Armataz_01_34.gif
 
so how did they taste Al........they look good.........i was going to do some this weekends smoke, but couldn't find any........
PDT_Armataz_01_33.gif
 
Wife didn't like them, Cole doesn't like mushrooms and Haley was sick.

I didn't think they were too bad, but I really don't know what all the "to do" is about them. I'm gonna try some sliced in butter & garlic today.

Anyway, good but not a "wow". Worth a try though, something different and quick.
 
Mine did NOT taste like steak. Onions may have covered it, but no steak taste here. I've heard all those stories and I was excited, then let down.

I have enough to try alone also. I guess we'll see.

I'll let you know.
 
They sure do look great the way you did them Al. Have had them in the past fixed other ways, from past experience I'm pretty sure they taste like steak to a vegetarian. To me thay tasted like a pretty good mushroom.
 
Xcap, YES. Good taste'n mushroom for sure, but not steak by any means.

I'm do'n one "steak" style right now. Gotta have bacon w/it.
PDT_Armataz_01_12.gif





Well, you'll see the bacon on the smoker. This is just before going on the smoker.
 
I don't know about tasting like a steak but they can taste like a mushroom that has been seasoned and cooked like a steak.
PDT_Armataz_01_18.gif



Personally, I love shrooms! The portabella has lots of meat to it and that makes it more lovable! To be honest it does not really have a strong flavor of anything, except the delicate flavor of mushroom.

Typically I dont scrape out the gills when I stuff them, leaves more of that great mushroom and then the stuffing can be more like a topping than a stuffing.

I think that I would have smoked them a bit longer to ensure that the entire mushroom was cooked through but I don't know how well yours were cooked. (and yes dem can be slippery little suckers!) I sometimes do them in the inside broiler and they cook fast at 45minutes.

My wife bought a couple of prestuffed on a styro tray the other day that were filled with some kind of veggie mix like a pico de gallo (SP) diced peppers, tomatos, onions, cilantro and topped with feta cheese. Those little buggers had a little unexpected bite to them! Although I kind of ruined my wifes dinning expeirence when I told her that the burning sensation meant that the shrooms were poison! (she is real gullable that way and I had to pick through the stuffing to point out the peppers before she would finish hers), next time I will just have to eat hers too, just to prove that they are not poison
icon_lol.gif
 
Thats good Zapper, real good.....and evil!
icon_twisted.gif


This last one I did I thought I over did it. Looked like hell. It was done right. All I did was add some McCormick garlic and onion stuff after I sprayed w/some 'pam' type stuff w/butter in it. laid some bacon over it after it had smoked a while and WOW! It was good, real good. I'm do'n 2 more, been on smoker only 10 min, chix done, ribs done, but I want some more mushrooms. Not steak, but VERY good just as they are w/no stuff'n.

I was really shocked and I don't think the bacon did much for it. Good shtuff!!!

I hope these turn out as good, wife will be happy!
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky