Smoke Hollow Charcoal Wagon at Sam's Club

Discussion in 'Charcoal Smokers' started by callaway, Mar 5, 2009.

  1. callaway

    callaway Newbie

    Does anyone on the forums have any experience with the Smoke Hollow Charcoal Wagon at Sam's Club? I have been thinking about buying one since they seem to be a little less expensive that the offset barrel smokers.

    Any advice?
  2. mikey

    mikey Smoking Fanatic

    Welcome to SMF. By chance, do you have a link for that smoker? :D
  3. howufiga

    howufiga Meat Mopper

    How much are these?
  4. pineywoods

    pineywoods Smoking Guru Staff Member Administrator Group Lead SMF Premier Member

  5. callaway

    callaway Newbie

  6. callaway

    callaway Newbie

    That's the one Pineywoods.
  7. mikey

    mikey Smoking Fanatic

  8. jdt

    jdt Smoking Fanatic SMF Premier Member

    sams has a charcoal grill without the sfb like that I was looking at but even on sams own website people are complaining about the adjustable tray cranks being cheasy and stripping out, not sure if its the same brand or not but check out the drive mechanics of them charcoal tray lifts well before buying
  9. I saw one last week when I was picking up some stuff at Sam's...I played with the cranks and did notice the slippage. Quite noticeable and it didn't seem like it would hold up to continuous usage.
  10. callaway

    callaway Newbie

    I also saw the unit without the sfb and noticed the cranks were suspect. I thought the cranks on the Smoke Hollow worked better and with the sfb I thought it would be better for smoking.

    Did you notice the crank problem on the Smoke Hollow or the other unit?
  11. callaway

    callaway Newbie

    I noticed on of these grills at Sam's Club for $229. Checked with the manager and he said it was a special buy from now until April. This is $40.00 cheaper than the last time I checked.

    At $229 I am thinking about getting one. It seems like a lot of grill for the price. Any opinions or thoughts would be appreciated.[
  12. afreetrapper

    afreetrapper Fire Starter

    My sister has one I tried to smoke with it yesterday using oak for heat with hickory. I had to leave the door to the firebox open to keep the fire from choking out even with all the vents open. I could not get the temperture above 180'. It might work using charcoal on the grill side and indirect heat. Like you would appreciate any input.
  13. ballagh

    ballagh Smoking Fanatic

    sams has it for $199.88 right now. Worth buying ya think?
  14. dirt guy

    dirt guy Smoking Fanatic

    They had them at my local Wal-Mart. It didn't look like a very durable unit. Pretty thin overall. Cranks didn't even work on the display model.
  15. I must say for the price, you could buy a Silver Smoker or Brinkman Smoke N Pit and do the mods and get a decent unit that's been tested by many here. I get consistent 4 hour burns of 220-260 with charcoal and chunks with my Silver Smoker. My .02
  16. grampyskids

    grampyskids Meat Mopper SMF Premier Member

    I picked up CG SNP at Orchard Hardware for $165 no tax. Look around. If you have patience, you will find the deal. I bought mine way ahead od schedule only because of price. It is sitting in the garage waiting for my smoking patio.
  17. 1granddaddy

    1granddaddy Newbie

    I have one and have the same issue with the firebox. Can anyone help
  18. stiffyman

    stiffyman Smoke Blower

    Hi all my friend purchased a grill much like this one, the opening from the fire box into the smoker(grill area) is nothing more then a slit, it about 1-1/2 inch X 6 inches, makes it hard to get temps above 200 and to hold it there. has anyone purchased the same if so did you make some mods to it?

Share This Page