Rump Roast VS Bottom Round Roast

Discussion in 'Beef' started by brokenwing, Jul 21, 2010.

  1. brokenwing

    brokenwing Meat Mopper SMF Premier Member

    Hey everyone, have not been around a while i threw my back out.  Got a question for the butchers here.  This is not smoking related, but when I cook up some of my family favorite pot roast, why is the rump roast so tender, and more expensive, verses if I use a bottom round roast its like eating leather and costs a few dollars cheaper.
     
  2. dutch

    dutch Smoking Guru Staff Member Administrator Group Lead OTBS Member SMF Premier Member

    Bottom round comes off of the rear leg. It's a leg muscle and does a lot of the work in walking. The rump is behind the hip and is located next to the loin primal where the sirloin, porterhouse and T-bone steaks come from.
     
    Last edited: Jul 21, 2010
  3. brokenwing

    brokenwing Meat Mopper SMF Premier Member

    Thanks dutch, i was wondering why, and now that explains it.  So I guess the rump roast is your most tender roast?
     
  4. pops6927

    pops6927 Smoking Guru Staff Member Moderator Group Lead OTBS Member SMF Premier Member

    Here's a picture of a gooseneck round which is the bottom and rump and eye of round together:

    [​IMG]

    You separate off the eye of the round and heel of the round and you're left with this:

    [​IMG]

    If you follow down the right hand side you come to a right angle notch before it goes to the point.  You'd separate it at that notch by cutting across it so the point is one piece and leaving the rest.  You've now separated the rump (point) from the bottom round.  However, if you look at the rump, you can see a similarity to a sirloin; that's because off that point is where the sirloin comes from.  The bottom round is used in the leg but the rump is used in the ..well. rump or fanny (ass) of the cattle, which is not load bearing and doesn't get exercised that much, no where's near as much as the bottom round (leg) of the animal.  You can cut off rump steaks from it and they're almost as good as sirloin.  Try it with bottom round and they're almost as good as Red Wings, lol!  Dutch is absolutely right.

    As far as the most tender?  Not necessarily.  You can roast a sirloin tip or a whole sirloin shell, (top butt) for a more tender roast, but for practical and mainstream economic reasons, a rump is a great dinner roast!

    Bottom round is best suited for swiss steak when cubed or cubed steak, stew beef, or pot roast (wet method vs. dry method or tenderized).  Or, from a smoking viewpoint, it makes excellent dried beef also as it's cured, smoked, then sliced paper thin!  You can also make jerky out of it if you have stout teeth (or diamond steel false teeth, lol!) when sliced with the grain.  Across the grain would definitely be better, however!
     
  5. brokenwing

    brokenwing Meat Mopper SMF Premier Member

    wow pops thanks so much.  I have always wondered about this.  Again I can not thank you enough. Now when I have questions about meat i will find dutch and pops.
     

Share This Page