Pork Butt comparison Brine vs Mr Brown

Discussion in 'Pork' started by herkysprings, Jun 7, 2009.

  1. herkysprings

    herkysprings Smoking Fanatic

    So I wanted to do a comparison of brining vs a regular pulled pork recipe. Also I was trying the new technique I learned about here, foiling the butts at 165.

    First the brined pork butt after 24 hours. I tried to stir it 1/2 way through.

    The Mr Brown butt was rubbed and wrapepd up tight for the same duration. Now both butts as they are ready to go into the smoker. The brine butt was taken out and rubbed in the pork rib rub (from Jeff), the night before. 7AM start time.

    MR Brown on the bottom. The Brined butt was very wet and it was hard to keep it rubbed, even with mustard. I smoked until 160 then wrapped in foil. Mr Brown basted with the sauce that recipe comes with, brined butt with apple juice and spiced rum.

    Then... well... I got a phone call to visit a friend, forgot to reset the smoker timer on my bradley, got a little "Beer brined" myself, and made it home after the smoker had been off for 30 minutes. The butts were at 191, so I quickly turned on the oven to finish at 205. FTC over night.

    I "pulled" the brine meat first. I quote "pulled" because this stuff fell apart itself. I did it all by hand, and I could keep larger chunks if I wanted, or shred the whole thing up.

    PS - iPhone cameras suck.

    The Mr Brown pulled the same way. Final yield with juice from each package.

    Vaunted Vinegar Sauce:
    1 cup Cider vinegar (i used apple cidar)
    1 tbl brown sugar
    1 tsp kosher salt
    1/2 tsp black pepper
    1/2 tsp Red Pepper Flakes

    combine, boil, then simmer for 10 min.

    I made 3 flavours. Brined butt with it's juice, Brown butt with it's juice and Brown butt with a vinegar sauce. I found that the brined one with the vinegar sauce tasted too much like really good salt and vinegar potato chip flavour, which I was not a fan of. If you like srtong salt / vinegar I suggest trying this.

    The brined meat was noticably more tender and had a salty flavour by itself. A taste test with other people said they liked the brine or the Brown / vinegar. It's hard at this point to say which was better, as they were 2 very different finishes.

    I can say I really liked the brined meat texture and flavour by itself, and even with its juice. With some sauce this would probably make very good pulled pork sandwiches.

    The Brown / vinegar tasted really good as is, so I would probably do that to just eat it straight.

    One last question, is my butts when I got home dropped from possibly 200 down to 181 before they started getting heated up again to 205 in the oven. I am wondering if maybe I could have over cooked them? They literally were falling apart, I could have dropped them from 5 feet high and they probably would have exploded apart.

    Finally, my prize at the end, BBQ PORK FAT. It tastes like bbq pork, nice and spicy, ready for use on some other dish!
  2. sumosmoke

    sumosmoke Master of the Pit OTBS Member SMF Premier Member

    LOVE THIS POST!! I've been meaning to brine a butt soon and haven't put myself to do it yet. Now I see your pics and the taste test review, I've got to do this soon, like .. next weekend .. [​IMG] !! Great post, points for your efforts!!
  3. rivet

    rivet Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    Excellent comparison test! Well done and thanks for sharing. Points to you for taking the time to evaluate and post! [​IMG]

    Beautiful pulled pork, as well. Those piles o'pork were beggin' for a cheap white bun and some coleslaw, my friend!
  4. the dude abides

    the dude abides Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    Nice looking stuff. Thanks for all the info.

  5. billbo

    billbo Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    Nice job! Thanks for the comparison!
  6. goobi99

    goobi99 Meat Mopper

    looks awesome!! i also recommend, from the same "smoke & spice " the carolina mustard. my wife has been using it on everything from pork to egg salad!!
  7. meatball

    meatball Smoking Fanatic OTBS Member

    Great post!! I'll be doing a butt this week for a weekend gathering and I'm definitely going to try the brine! Is the pork falling apart a bad thing? Sounds like it made for easy pullin' and as long as it tasted good...
  8. Herkysprings, what was your brine soulution?

    Both look very good in the q-view.

    thanks for sharing,
  9. jjrokkett

    jjrokkett Meat Mopper

    Great looking qview! [​IMG]
  10. flash

    flash Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    And the pictures are big too [​IMG]

    Who needs more salt in their diet [​IMG]
    But you gotta experiment. [​IMG]
  11. cajunsmoke13

    cajunsmoke13 Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    Thanks for the researching it and letting us know the results. Pics look fine to me and don't look too big on my screen. Nice job...PP looks great
  12. flash

    flash Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    Only the first and third photos spill off the screen, but maybe you have more than a 19 inch monitor?
  13. cajunsmoke13

    cajunsmoke13 Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    no, 15"...none run off the screen on my comp.
  14. herkysprings

    herkysprings Smoking Fanatic

    The brine was actually posted by another user no these forums last week or so. I dont have it in front of me, but if he/she speaks up, it was listed in the post.

    Also I realize the picture of the BBQ pork fat is pretty much useless, but... it was so tasty! Gonna make some hash browns or something with it.
  15. flash

    flash Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    You got a very high screen resolution then.
  16. onthewater

    onthewater Newbie

    Hmmmm.  Try making some biscuits and gravy with that bbq pork fat.  Tho I be the has would be awesome.

Share This Page