Newbie about to purchase my first smoker!

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Eugene Breindel

Newbie
Original poster
Oct 19, 2017
2
0
St. Marys, PA
Hello everyone! I am new to the forum and smoking. I visited my brother in Montana this summer. He has a Masterbuilt 40" smoker and I helped him with understanding it's uses just by reading thoroughly the manual/cookbook that came with it. We successfully smoked/cooked 2 whole chickens, a rack of ribs and some Salmon. The salmon needed to have close temperature control to keep the fat from cooking out, and the smoker overshot the temp too much and that occurred to a small extent. I was thinking of getting the same smoker for myself but wondered if there was a better and comparable model from another company. I was looking at the Smoke Hollow smokers in a Cabelas recently. How do they stack up? Any other brand suggestions?
As a novice, I think I would have better results learning with a smoker that has some tighter (digital) controls. I also want to cold smoke cheese and I don't know if an electric smoker will be able to produce smoke at those low temperature ranges to adequately smoke the cheese. I would think that having the heating element inside the unit would make too much heat for the cheese to smoke without melting. Any suggestions would be appreciated.
PS: I live in the climate of NW Pennsylvania
 
Eugene - Since you asked; you might want to look at the Smokin-it (SI) line of smokers. The 'D' models have a PID for accuracy. They are pricey when compared to the offerings from Masterbuilt and Smoke Hollow. You could also visit the Cookshack (CS) website. They also offer digitally controlled smokers. I have used both the SI and the CS smokers and they are top notch. I have not had any temperature issues. Since you mentioned Smoke Hollow, try looking at the SmokeTronix. It is digital. Here are some links within this forum to help you out. Happy reading and good luck. Oh, and welcome to the forum. Dave
https://smokingmeatforums.com/index.php?search/19165/&q=smokin-it&o=relevance
https://smokingmeatforums.com/index.php?search/19166/&q=cookshack&o=relevance
https://smokingmeatforums.com/index.php?search/19162/&q=smoketronix&o=relevance
 
I have a MES40 and have had good luck with it.

Full disclosure...
  • I did have to replace the meat probe about every year or two.
  • The control panel also had to be replaced at 3 years.
  • Now my temperature sensor for the MES40 is acting up and also needs to be replaced.

That being said...
  • Masterbuilt customer service has been great
  • I love the "set it and forget it" convenience I get with the MES40 and an AMNPS
  • I would still buy this smoker again if I had to replace it
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky