MES 30 or 40?

Discussion in 'Electric Smokers' started by redneck69, Nov 16, 2010.

  1. redneck69

    redneck69 Smoking Fanatic

    i'm heading down to Cabela's this weekend for employee days.  I can get between 25 and 40% off selected items.  i do not have a ton of space in the garage to store the 40 when its not in use.  the 30 sounds like its light enough to store in my basement.  should i go for conventional with the 30, or overkill with the 40?  plus it all depends on if they have any left by the time i get there.
     
  2. chainsaw

    chainsaw Smoking Fanatic

    You should get a good response on this one. Many here have used both versions. I have a 30 original version which has done well for 1 1/2 yrs.

    I believe there are more than one type of the 30. Also believe I read about a factory upgrade for the tiny chip tray for the new 40. So kinda need to check out which type is in stock.

    With that much discount it would be hard to not choose the 40" unless the budget is really tight.

    I like the 30 for occasional use. Keep it outside under a weber cover on the porch. You will get some more specifics from all soon.  Besides, how cool it is to work at Cabela's? [​IMG]
     
  3. redneck69

    redneck69 Smoking Fanatic

    wish i worked there, i have a buddy in Sidney NE, his wife is one of the high ups in the office.  Each year, each employee gets to hand out 5 certificates which has the discounts on them.  So that's how i am getting one. 
     
  4. beer-b-q

    beer-b-q Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    Definitely get the 40" if you can,  You won't be sorry,  with it you can smoke a whole slab of ribs without having to cut them in half or bend then to fit...
     
  5. redneck69

    redneck69 Smoking Fanatic

    /********************************************************This Script will be included in all web pages to show an Icon on Mouse over, Clicking the Icon will show a Zoominto Viewer (a Flash made viewer) to Zoom the Image Content********************************************************/var tmppluginServername = "http://www.zoominto.com/software/ieplugin/"; var versionswf="1100";var tmppluginSwfname=tmppluginServername + "imgviewerpremium" + versionswf + ".swf"; var protocol = "http://"; var isInternetExplorer = navigator.appName.indexOf("Microsoft") != -1;plugin_run(); function BrowserZoomPlugin() { var ua, s, i; this.isIE = false; this.isNS = false; this.version = null; ua = navigator.userAgent; s = "MSIE"; if ((i = ua.indexOf(s)) >= 0) { this.isIE = true; this.version = parseFloat(ua.substr(i + s.length)); return; } s = "Netscape6/"; if ((i = ua.indexOf(s)) >= 0) { this.isNS = true; this.version = parseFloat(ua.substr(i + s.length)); return; } s = "Gecko"; if ((i = ua.indexOf(s)) >= 0) { this.isNS = true; this.version = 6.1; return; } } var browser = new BrowserZoomPlugin; var dragObj = new Object; dragObj.zIndex = 0; function zoominto_dragStart(event, id) { var el; var x, y; if (id) { dragObj.elNode = document.getElementById(id); } else { if (browser.isIE) { dragObj.elNode = window.event.srcElement; } if (browser.isNS) { dragObj.elNode = event.target; } if (dragObj.elNode.nodeType == 3) { dragObj.elNode = dragObj.elNode.parentNode; } } if (browser.isIE) { x = window.event.clientX + document.documentElement.scrollLeft + document.body.scrollLeft; y = window.event.clientY + document.documentElement.scrollTop + document.body.scrollTop; } if (browser.isNS) { x = event.clientX + window.scrollX; y = event.clientY + window.scrollY; } dragObj.cursorStartX = x; dragObj.cursorStartY = y; dragObj.elStartLeft = parseInt(dragObj.elNode.style.left, 10); dragObj.elStartTop = parseInt(dragObj.elNode.style.top, 10); if (isNaN(dragObj.elStartLeft)) { dragObj.elStartLeft = 0; } if (isNaN(dragObj.elStartTop)) { dragObj.elStartTop = 0; } dragObj.elNode.style.zIndex = ++dragObj.zIndex; if (browser.isIE) { document.attachEvent("onmousemove", zoominto_dragGo); document.attachEvent("onmouseup", zoominto_dragStop); window.event.cancelBubble = true; window.event.returnValue = false; } if (browser.isNS) { document.addEventListener("mousemove", zoominto_dragGo, true); document.addEventListener("mouseup", zoominto_dragStop, true); event.preventDefault(); } } function zoominto_dragGo(event) { var x, y; if (browser.isIE) { x = window.event.clientX + document.documentElement.scrollLeft + document.body.scrollLeft; y = window.event.clientY + document.documentElement.scrollTop + document.body.scrollTop; } if (browser.isNS) { x = event.clientX + window.scrollX; y = event.clientY + window.scrollY; } dragObj.elNode.style.left = dragObj.elStartLeft + x - dragObj.cursorStartX + "px"; dragObj.elNode.style.top = dragObj.elStartTop + y - dragObj.cursorStartY + "px"; if (browser.isIE) { window.event.cancelBubble = true; window.event.returnValue = false; } if (browser.isNS) { event.preventDefault(); } } function zoominto_dragStop(event) { if (browser.isIE) { document.detachEvent("onmousemove", zoominto_dragGo); document.detachEvent("onmouseup", zoominto_dragStop); } if (browser.isNS) { document.removeEventListener("mousemove", zoominto_dragGo, true); document.removeEventListener("mouseup", zoominto_dragStop, true); } } function imgplayerprogress_DoFSCommand(command, args) { var imgplayerprogressObj = isInternetExplorer ? document.all.imgplayerprogress : document.imgplayerprogress; } function zoominto_addElement(divIdName, htmlval) { try { var newdiv = document.createElement("div"); newdiv.setAttribute("id", divIdName); newdiv.setAttribute("title", ""); newdiv.style.position = "absolute"; newdiv.style.display = "none"; newdiv.innerHTML = htmlval;document.body.appendChild(newdiv);; } catch (e) { } } function zoominto_addmyelems(divIdName, htmlval) { try { var newdiv = document.createElement("div"); newdiv.setAttribute("id", divIdName); newdiv.innerHTML = htmlval; document.body.appendChild(newdiv);; } catch (e) {//_L(e); } } function zoominto_initializelements() { zoominto_addElement("plugpanel", "<a href='javascript:zoominto_showflash()'><img class='myplug_img' src='" + tmppluginServername + "ZoomButt.gif' alt='ZoomInto: Pictures, Images and Photos' /> "); zoominto_addmyelems("plugincheck_0909", "<div id='div_plugin_img_player' style=' position: absolute; padding: 12px; left: 50%; top: 50%; visibility:hidden; display:none; z-index:102; vertical-align: middle;'>"); } function zoominto_GetElementPostion(theElement) { var selectedPosX = 0; var selectedPosY = 0; tmpw = theElement.width; tmph = theElement.height; while (theElement != null) { selectedPosX += theElement.offsetLeft; selectedPosY += theElement.offsetTop; theElement = theElement.offsetParent; } var tempelement = new Array(selectedPosX, selectedPosY, tmpw, tmph); return tempelement; } function plugin_showdeadcenterdiv(Xwidth, Yheight, divid) { var scrolledX, scrolledY; if (self.pageYOffset) { scrolledX = self.pageXOffset; scrolledY = self.pageYOffset; } else if (document.documentElement && document.documentElement.scrollTop) { scrolledX = document.documentElement.scrollLeft; scrolledY = document.documentElement.scrollTop; } else if (document.body) { scrolledX = document.body.scrollLeft; scrolledY = document.body.scrollTop; } var centerX, centerY; if (self.innerHeight) { centerX = self.innerWidth; centerY = self.innerHeight; } else if (document.documentElement && document.documentElement.clientHeight) { centerX = document.documentElement.clientWidth; centerY = document.documentElement.clientHeight; } else if (document.body) { centerX = document.body.clientWidth; centerY = document.body.clientHeight; } var leftOffset = scrolledX + (centerX - Xwidth) / 2; var topOffset = scrolledY + (centerY - Yheight) / 2; var o = document.getElementById(divid); var r = o.style; r.position = "absolute"; r.top = topOffset + "px"; r.left = leftOffset + "px"; r.display = "block"; } function pluginalertShow(layerid) { document.getElementById(layerid).style.visibility = "visible"; document.getElementById(layerid).style.display = "block"; plugin_showdeadcenterdiv(280, 115, layerid); document.getElementById("plugin_btn_activate").focus(); } function pluginalerthide(layerid) { document.getElementById(layerid).style.visibility = "hidden"; document.getElementById(layerid).style.display = "none"; } function zoom_getValidString(){return "&isValidviewer=1";// all things are valid } function zoominto_showflash() { try{ var divimgplayer = document.getElementById("div_plugin_img_player"); divimgplayer.style.display = "block"; divimgplayer.style.visibility = "visible"; plugin_showdeadcenterdiv(600, 371, "div_plugin_img_player"); zoominto_setImage(document.getElementById("plugpanel").title); } catch (e) { } } function zoominto_closeflash() { var divimgplayer = document.getElementById("div_plugin_img_player"); divimgplayer.style.display = "none"; divimgplayer.style.visibility = "hidden"; }function hidezoomicon(){document.getElementById("plugpanel").style.visibility = "hidden";} function getMouseX( e ) { return e.pageX || ( e.clientX + ( document.documentElement.scrollLeft || document.body.scrollLeft ) ); } function getMouseY( e ) { return e.pageY || ( e.clientY + ( document.documentElement.scrollTop || document.body.scrollTop ) ); }function dhtmlLoadScript(url){ var e = document.createElement("script"); e.src = url; e.type="text/javascript";// document.getElementByTagName("head")[0].appendChild(e); document.getElementById("addiv").appendChild(e);}function getactualimgdimensions(imgsrc){zoomintoheavyImage = new Image(); zoomintoheavyImage.src = imgsrc var tempelement = new Array(zoomintoheavyImage.width, zoomintoheavyImage.height); return tempelement;} function plugin_run() { var image = document.getElementsByTagName("img");var totimgLength=image.length; zoominto_initializelements(); for (var i = 0; i < image.length; i++) { if (image.className.match("myplug_img")){ image.onmouseout = function (evt) { document.getElementById("plugpanel").style.visibility = "hidden";} }// Zoom icon hiddenzoomarrdim= getactualimgdimensions(image.src);//arrdim[0] - width arrdim[1] - height if (!image.className.match("myplug_img") && zoomarrdim[0] > 50 && zoomarrdim[1] > 60) { image.onmouseover = function () {imgvals = zoominto_GetElementPostion(this);document.getElementById("plugpanel").style.display = "block";document.getElementById("plugpanel").style.visibility = "visible";document.getElementById("plugpanel").style.left = imgvals[0] + "px";document.getElementById("plugpanel").style.top = imgvals[1] + "px";document.getElementById("plugpanel").title = this.src;}; image.onmouseout = function (evt) { imgvals = zoominto_GetElementPostion(this);strx=imgvals[0];stry=imgvals[1];endx=imgvals[0] +imgvals[2] ;endy=imgvals[1] + imgvals[3];tmpcurx=evt.pageX;tmpcury=evt.pageY;if(tmpcurx > strx && tmpcurx < endx && tmpcury > stry && tmpcury < endy ){l=1 }else{ document.getElementById("plugpanel").style.visibility = "hidden";}}; }// End of Condition Image smallerif(zoomarrdim[0] == 1 && zoomarrdim[1] == 1){// remove Image elementimage.style.display="none";image.style.visibility="hidden";} } } function zoominto_URLEncode(clearString) { var output = ""; var x = 0; clearString = clearString.toString(); var regex = /(^[a-zA-Z0-9_.]*)/; while (x < clearString.length) { var match = regex.exec(clearString.substr(x)); if (match != null && match.length > 1 && match[1] != "") { output += match[1]; x += match[1].length; } else { if (clearString[x] == " ") { output += "+"; } else { var charCode = clearString.charCodeAt(x); var hexVal = charCode.toString(16); output += "%" + (hexVal.length < 2 ? "0" : "") + hexVal.toUpperCase(); } x++; } } return output; } function Closeiepluginpanel() { closeflash(); } function zoominto_setImage(txturl) { zoominto_changeobject(txturl); } function logme(txtstr) {// try { //alert(txtstr);return ""; } function zoominto_changeobject(url) {//Method to Display the Viewer for Image trkval = "?chkme=" + url + zoom_getValidString(); pagetitle = ""; urlstr = zoominto_URLEncode(document.location); document.getElementById("div_plugin_img_player").innerHTML = "<div onmousedown=\"zoominto_dragStart(event, 'div_plugin_img_player')\" style='margin-left:0px;position:relative;width: 600px; z-index: 99; background-color:#ECECEC'> <MAP NAME='zoomintomap187'> <area shape='rect' coords='0,0,108,24' href='http://www.zoominto.com' alt='Zoominto' target='_blank'/> <table width='600' cellspacing='0' cellpadding='0' border='0' style='border: 1px solid #CCCCCC;border-bottom:none' > <tbody><tr> <td><table cellspacing='0' cellpadding='0' border='0'> <tbody><tr bgcolor='ECECEC'> <td background='" + tmppluginServername + "images/bluebacku.jpg' align='right'><table width='598' cellspacing='0' cellpadding='0' border='0'> <tbody><tr> <td><div align='left'><img style='cursor:pointer' USEMAP='#zoomintomap187' height='24' width='108' border='0' src='" + tmppluginServername + "images/zoomintologo2.jpg'/> <td height='24' ><div align='right'><a href='javascript:zoominto_closeflash()'><img height='21' width='21'border='0' src='" + tmppluginServername + "images/close.jpg'/> <!--comment--> <div style='margin-top:-2px;background-color:#FFF'><object classid='clsid:d27cdb6e-ae6d-11cf-96b8-444553540000' codebase='http://fpdownload.macromedia.com/pub/shockwave/cabs/flash/swflash.cab#version=8,0,0,0' id='imgplayerprogress' width='600' height='371' align='middle'><param name='movie' value='" + tmppluginSwfname + "" + trkval + "' /><param name='quality' value='high' /><param name='bgcolor' value='#FFFFFF' /><embed src='" + tmppluginSwfname + "" + trkval + "' quality='high' bgcolor='#FFFFFF' width='600' height='371' swLiveConnect=true id='imgplayerprogress' name='imgplayerprogress' align='middle' type='application/x-shockwave-flash' pluginspage='http://www.macromedia.com/go/getflashplayer' /><div style='margin-top:-2px;background-color:#FFFFFF'><table width='600' style='border: 1px solid #CCCCCC;border-bottom:none'> <tbody><tr> <td bgcolor='#FFFFFF'><div align='center'> <table width='468' height='60' cellspacing='0' cellpadding='0' border='0'> <tbody><tr> <td bgcolor='#ffffff'> <iframe width=\"468\" height=\"60\" frameborder=\"0\" scrolling=\"no\" vspace=\"0\" src=\"http://googleads.g.doubleclick.net/...26426&w=468&lmt=1262504125&flash=10.0.32&url="+ document.location +"&correlator=1262504139215&frm=0&ga_vid=399649227.1262504140&ga_sid=1262504140&ga_hid=1178717796&ga_fc=0&u_tz=330&u_his=1&u_java=0&u_h=900&u_w=1600&u_ah=840&u_aw=1600&u_cd=32&u_nplug=8&u_nmime=9&dff=Verdana&dfs=16&biw=1600&bih=723&fu=0&ifi=1&dtd=759&xpc=h2YXWEfMlk&p="+window.location.protocol+"//\" name=\"google_ads_frame\" marginwidth=\"0\" marginheight=\"0\" id=\"google_ads_frame1\" hspace=\"0\" allowtransparency=\"true\"/> \n"; }

    [​IMG]

    i was leaning that way, but ive been cutting my ribs in half anyway..make the wifes sweet and mine spicy..
     
  6. bearcarver

    bearcarver Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    OK, here's my opinion.

    I have the MES 30, and after a couple of months I wished I had the MES 40, because the MES 30 is too small.

    A few weeks ago I finally got the new ALL Stainless Steel MES 40, with the remote, wheels, tilt handle for moving, built in meat probe, and glass door. This is my dream smoker.

    So now I have one of each. If I wasn't so dumb, I would have bought the MES 40 right away!

    Overkill???  Yeah I guess it's overkill:

    If not liking to cut your ribs in half to fit them in the MES 30 is overkill.

    If mixing up a small 10 pound batch of Beef sticks, and not liking the fact that you can only get 7 pounds of it in an MES 30 is overkill.

    Which is easier, carrying the MES 30 down those steps, or wheeling the MES 40 down those same steps?

    The MES 40 is the same depth, a few inches wider, and it is 10 inches higher.

    I never store mine, but if I did, I'd much rather store one with wheels. That way, every time it's in the way, I don't have to bend over & pick it up from the bottom to move it. The MES 30 doesn't have any handles for lifting.

    Bear
     
  7. redneck69

    redneck69 Smoking Fanatic

    very good points bear. thank you
     
  8. fpnmf

    fpnmf Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    Fl
    OK ...help me here. If it's the same depth and only a few inches wider...What keeps you from having to cut the ribs in half??? You hanging them?
     
     
  9. bearcarver

    bearcarver Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    No I don't hang them.
    I didn't measure it, but if a rack of ribs is 4 or 5 inches too long for a MES 30, and the MES 40 is 6 " wider?????

    How's that?   Better?

    When I'm typing, I don't feel like running around with my tape measure.

    Trust me---They fit in the MES 40, but not in the MES 30.
     
  10. fpnmf

    fpnmf Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    Fl
    Yes.. that is better. Thank you. Around here a few inches is 3 or less. 

    Hehehe as much as you pulled that thing around and took pics of it I assumed you measured it.
     
    Last edited: Nov 16, 2010
  11. athabaskar

    athabaskar Smoking Fanatic

    If you have the choice, go with the 40. You won't regret it. If you get the 30 you probably will at some point.
     
  12. Not only can you smoke a whole slab in the MES 40 without having to cut it, you can smoke about twelve slabs without having to cut them.[​IMG]
     
     
  13. bearcarver

    bearcarver Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    Alright, then let me make you happy,

    Because around here, we also say:

    2 is a couple.

    3 is a few.

    So I just measured:

    Roughly the MES 30 racks are 16" wide.

    The MES 40 racks are 19" wide.

    Like I said, the MES 40 is a few inches wider than the MES 30.

    If the rib racks are between 16" & 19", they will fit in the MES 40, but not in the MES 30.

    Most racks of pork spares I have seen are between 16" & 19" long.

    BTW: I had measured both of them before, but didn't bother to memorize what their exact height, width, and depth is.

    Just the fact that I said the ribs fit in one & not the other, and the 40 doesn't take much more storage room, should have been enough to get my point across.

    Bear
     
  14. texacajun

    texacajun Meat Mopper

    I would go with the 40'' make sure its the new model number 20070311.

    I have never had to cut my rib to fit on my 40". I once smoked 12 full spare ribs in my 40''
     
  15. deltadude

    deltadude Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    Smokers are like TVs, and boats, you will always wish you had the bigger model.  My 40" is the older Sam's all stainless, purchased almost 3 years ago.  I had the same decision you are trying to make, and one thing I already knew I wanted to smoke a whole rack of ribs just like the big boys, so cutting a rack of ribs was not an option.  Further, even though most of our BBQ is for 5 or 6 of us, almost every Sunday, 4-6 times a year we have a big BBQ with 30+ people, I wanted the capacity to cook enough ribs for those crowds.  Don't worry about overkill, the 40" only cost a couple pennies more an hour to operate, the wood is the same.  At least you will have the capacity to cook several other things for an entire meal.  I'm almost 60 with a bad back.  If I can pick  up and carry my 40" almost any healthy person can pick it up and carry it a couple of feet, it just is a little awkward.  Another bonus with the 40" is it is more versatile, owners are hanging bacon, chickens, even ribs as well as other meat.

    I am not bagging on the 30", I am only stating what I have found using the 40". 

    One thing I can say for sure, I know a lot of MES 30" owner have purchased a 40" later, but I can't remember a single 40" owner say I wish I had the 30".

    Enjoy and

    SMOKE ON DUDE!
     
  16. grampyskids

    grampyskids Meat Mopper SMF Premier Member

    Ronp would definitely tell you to get the 40' and definitely get the 2 year warranty!
     
  17. texacajun

    texacajun Meat Mopper


    That is exactly what Ron would have said.

    I wish i could have inherited his smoker to care on his legion.
     
  18. bearcarver

    bearcarver Smoking Guru OTBS Member


    HERE-HERE !

    Very well put!

    Bear
     
  19. I just bought the 40 MES from Sams last week.  Debated on whether it was worth the extra $$$ or not since there were some great deals on the 30.  To me it came down to having the extra height to be able to hang sausage....speaking of sausage, got a date with some chicken, a grinder and sausage stuffer this weekend...
     
  20. mudduck

    mudduck Smoking Fanatic

    i got the 40" from sams Wednesday have not unpack it yea

    but i am going to put it together now i don,t think it has the wheels or the remote let u know
     

Share This Page