How good is the Smoke Hollow 44" smoker ?

Discussion in 'Propane Smokers' started by jrod62, Feb 26, 2013.

  1. jrod62

    jrod62 Smoking Guru Group Lead OTBS Member

    Was at Sam's today and seen this smoker. Looks like a lot of room in it. Before I buy it

    like to find out more about it . So any info will be helpful. Does the AMNPS burn good in it ?

    Temp control ?

    Thanks for any help on this.
  2. mhchops

    mhchops Smoke Blower

    I was considering that smoker myself but read lots of bad and some good also i think the size is great but the way i understand it really eats propane like almost a 20 lbs tank on a good smoke. There is a smoke hollow post that you can read, its under propane smokers i dont know how to link you there or i would

    nabor25 likes this.
  3. jhs1957

    jhs1957 Newbie

    I just bought this from asms about 3weeks ago new to smoking ,bit o think it will work just fine.
  4. jrod62

    jrod62 Smoking Guru Group Lead OTBS Member

    Just wondering if it will go low enough for smoking sausage .
  5. jhs1957

    jhs1957 Newbie

    ok I am going to try this again. Tried posting last night from my phone and the touch screen keypad is very touchy. so far i have smoked a pork loin, fatty, and 4 slabs of ribs, temp was at or around 225 -250 at that temp it is hard to keep chunks from burning. I also smoked  a batch of jerky and a batch of snack sticks. the snack sticks came great. I started them smoking at 120 then bumped up

    the temp by 10 or 15 degrees every hour untill they were done. i had excellent smoke with these. I was able to set knob by pushing in and turning to offf position until flame was very low with only one burner.  the ambient temp was somewhere in low 30 upper 20s . I am not sure i should be doing this or not but flame did not go out. i have not tried this when smoking at 225- 250 range am a

    little leary if flame goes out and other burner is still going if i would have a problem

    the therm with unit is off and for now i am using a oven therm problem with that is half way threw smoke you can not see threw widow anymore

    as far as propane im not really sure i have one small tank and one larger tank of rv . i switched from little tank to big tank when i went to smoke the ribs . I did not want to run out in middle as i was in

    house checking occasionally because was so cold that day.Overall the food has been coming out good ..
    beartoo likes this.
  6. s2k9k

    s2k9k AMNPS Test Group

    Ed, I don't know about the Smoke Hollow but I do know a lot of people have had a very hard time with the AMNPS and propane smokers, the burner just burns up too much O2. But there has been really good results with the AMNTS (The Tube) and propane smokers.
  7. jhs1957

    jhs1957 Newbie

    I was able to get temp as low as 120. I used one burner and turned towards off position untill flame was very low . Worked really good and wind did not blow out. ambient temp low 30s.  I smoked snack sticks and they came out great. I had about 6 hours and good smoke. I smoked a batch of jerky that came out good but I overdried them for my taste  but that i figured was me learning the smoker... I smoked 4 racks of ribs last sat. that came out very good. smoked at 225- 250 range . I am haveing trouble with smoke flare ups at this range.. same problem when I smoked a loin... I believe it would work by setting the one burner like I am doing snack sticks and the other burner higher . My concern is if the low burner goes out. whcich it hasnt yet.

    As for the propane usage I am not sure I have one 20 lb and one tank that is bigger I use in rv. I swithed from the smaller one to the bigger one when I went to do the ribs. both still have propane left in them
    jrod62 likes this.
  8. jhs1957

    jhs1957 Newbie

    I am sorry for posting twice I did not see that it was being held...
  9. jrod62

    jrod62 Smoking Guru Group Lead OTBS Member

    Jhs1957, thanks for the info, that's was what I was looking for, if I would be able to get the temp down to 130 without the flame going out.
    I might PM you for more info, after I look at it some more .
  10. kathrynn

    kathrynn Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    I use a Camp Chef Smoke Vault...propane smoker.  I have the   AMNTS (The Tube).  My smoker doesn't eat propane.  I can do many many smokes on one 20 pound tank.

    The company is coming out with a 40" smoker later this year too.

  11. Hi jrod I have the 44 inches by Smoke Hollow and I really like it I only use one of the burners and it isn't hard on propane I have did about 4 or 5 long smokes and its still on the same 20 lb tank I did put a neele valve on it to control the temps better and the tube pellet  smoker from Todd works Fine I'm not sorry I got it It does leak a bit of smoke around the door but I can deal with that For the money I give it a thumbs up
    jrod62 and richclark like this.
  12. jrod62

    jrod62 Smoking Guru Group Lead OTBS Member

    Thanks for info.
    I might try the mailbox mod. For the AMNPS.
    I have been thinking about trying the AMNTS.
    So might have to place an order for it.
  13. jrod62

    jrod62 Smoking Guru Group Lead OTBS Member

    Sound likes the AMNTS is the way to go .
    I will add a needle valve to it.
    Were do you put the AMNTS in the smoker ?
    Last edited: Feb 27, 2013
  14. jhs1957

    jhs1957 Newbie

    If u put a neadle valve how will that work with two burners will u be ableTo have one on low for chips and one on say med for 225 temp
  15. jrod If I have the right side burner on I place the tube smoker beside the left side air intake and next to the left chip box
  16. jrod62

    jrod62 Smoking Guru Group Lead OTBS Member

  17. I just got the same smoker and I smoked some pork loin and it worked great . I was wondering if anyone has smoked cheese on the 44 in smoker ? If so how did it turn out ?
  18. aland

    aland Fire Starter

    Hi- I use my 44 to smoke cheese, Spam, boloney, boiled eggs, nuts, etc and use the AMZNTS. I use no heat. If you go above 90* or so, the cheese will get soft and, believe me, sag thru the grates. Tastes great but a real booger to get out. I keep mine in the car shed out of the sun but I have to wait for a cool day. If it's 90* or higher, it's risky. You can freeze some jugs with water and put them in there to keep the temps down, but put them in a pan of some sort to catch the condensation. aland.
  19. aland

    aland Fire Starter

    Also, I forgot, if you have trouble keeping the temps down when you do use heat, set the knob on HI, then turn back towards OFF to get a "pilot light" like flame. Works for me. Good luck, aland. 
  20. Thanks for the tips . I will try them

Share This Page