Help !!!! Where did I go wrong?

Discussion in 'Grilling Pork' started by vettman, Jul 17, 2011.

  1. I smoked a butt today and it was not good. I started with a 4 lb boston butt. Come to find out it was boneless. Slim pickings here on saturday mornings. Anyway, I rubbed it last night and kept in frig. I got smoker ready and put it on til 160* (about 3 hours) then I double wrapped in foil and put back in til 206*.  I let it set foiled on counter for an hour and a half.  Here's how it came out.: Not much bark, and very little smoke flavor, almost like I had done it in an oven! I used hickory chips. I have an electric upright smoker. Why hardly any smoke flavor?  I,ve done ribs that were good. Anyway I quit using chips after 3 hours when I wrapped it. Total time was 6 and a half hours. You pros help me out please!  -Thanks
  2. meateater

    meateater Smoking Guru SMF Premier Member

    We need more info. What smoker you have and a few pics would help. Then the CSI's  "Carnage Scene Investigators" can step in. [​IMG]
  3. It's a Masterbuilt upright electric smoker from lowes. (fathers day present). Sorry, I didn't think to get pics.
  4. oldschoolbbq

    oldschoolbbq Smoking Guru OTBS Member

       Vetteman,IMHO you did bake them?[​IMG]  The wrapping softens the bark wioth all that moisture in there.I don't wrap anything and get good results.I'm not a Pro.,just a BYC and the Family enjoys my Food.

       I don't know what your cooking on ,but (my) first rule is'don't open the cooker until it is about done.How do I do that,I figgure my time and close the lid,hod it as close as I can to my cooking temp. ,and when the time is ab out up,I check IMT and go from there.[​IMG]

  5. eman

    eman Smoking Guru Staff Member Moderator OTBS Member

    160° in 3 hrs is kinda short time? Usually takes longer than that .What temp were you smoking at?

     Wrapping in foil does take away from the bark.  You may need a lil more (heavier)smoke for a butt than you do for ribs
  6. smokinal

    smokinal Smoking Guru Staff Member Moderator OTBS Member ★ Lifetime Premier ★

    Did you use a digital therm. or did you rely on the controller setting. Sounds to me like it cooked awfully fast. If you want more smoke flavor & bark try not foiling next time.
  7. turfguy

    turfguy Fire Starter

    I'm not sure that's the problem, IMHO. I always foil and never have a problem with my bark not surviving the oven. It will soften it a bit (which I like) but it won't disappear.
  8. It got to 206? Did it almost fall apart when you pulled it. If not it may not have really hit 206. Check your thermometers.

Share This Page