HELP! First smoker purchase in the $150 - $250 range

Discussion in 'Propane Smokers' started by hoser45, Nov 14, 2011.

  1. hoser45

    hoser45 Newbie

    Hi all. Newbie to smoking (not eating it, just doing it). My very first post here on the forum. So what better question than that of my very first smoker purchase. I did a search but some came up older and want the latest recommendations!

    I'm in central valley of CA,  Fresno. Believe it or not, it does get pretty cold here when fog hits in the valley. I've decided on propane, vertical. I was going to quickly run out and the the MASTER FORGE at Lowes, but a quick search made it seems like it has smoke leakage problem and thin walls. I do like the idea of a separate opening for the water/chip area to keep heat in.

    I'm looking for suggestions in the $150  $250 price range. Ideally I wanted to find one in stock locally so I can smoke Turkey this Thanksgiving, but for the absolute right one, I'll mail order it. Some that I found, or have interested in me due to local delivery option are as follows:

    ~ LOWES

    Master Forge|0||p_product_qty_sales_dollar|1&facetInfo=

    ~ WALMART:

    Great Outdoors Smoky Mountain

    Char-Broil 578-sq in Vertical Gas Smoker


    Landmann 38" Two drawer

    These are the easiest access for me. Of these, would any of these make a good first smoker? If there's another that would be better, let me know. Thanks in advance!
  2. michael ark

    michael ark Master of the Pit

    I've had a GOSM  since June and love it.They are so poplar they have their own group here.
  3. hoser45

    hoser45 Newbie

    So what do you think of that Landmann (gosm) model from Costco? Seems like the Big Block is more popular, but there's only two of us at home with only occasional big party family cooking. Does size of the BB lend itself more for commercial or catering applications? Here's the info:

    Ready to start Smoking?  Or maybe it is time for the ease and convenience of Gas smoking instead of Charcoal smoking?   This Great Outdoor™ SMOKY MOUNTAIN SERIES™ Gas Smoker is what you are looking for.  

    From ribs to turkeys, this popular vertical 38” tall smoking chamber offers a large 980 square inch smoking area on 5 chrome-plated cooking racks.  Utilizing LP Gas and a rotary ignition, the 16,000btu cast brass burner provides the temperature range and control for most common smoking applications.  The top chimney and side chrome-plated damper vents allow for fine tuning of the heat for optimum temperature control.

    Made of heavy duty steel construction and stabilized by wide stance legs, this smoker will provide years of smoking excellence.  The two “easy access” drawers you to check your water and wood without opening main smoking chamber door.

    • Heavy steel construction
    • Magnetic door closure
    • 16,000 BTUs 
    • 980 sq in smoking area
    • 5 chrome-plated cooking racks
    • Rotary ignition system
    • Strategically located temperature gauge on door
    • Wide stance legs for stability
    • Easy access drawers to access both the water pan and wood chip box without opening the main smoking chamber door
    • Durable large plastic door and drawer handles
    • Heavy duty side handles
    • Large Porcelain-coated steel water pan
    • Large steel wood chip box with vented lid
    • Top adjustable chimney and side damper vents
    • Cast Brass burner cap for long life and carries a 10 year warranty
    • CSA certified
    Based on 980 square inch smoking area, how wide is this model? Too narrow? Thanks.
  4. bratrules

    bratrules Smoking Fanatic

    Welcome aboard!!! well i have the master forge smoker and with a few mods the smoker works really well for that price!! Ive done mostly everything you can think of on it and it performs like a champ.
  5. hoser45

    hoser45 Newbie

    What mods were needed?
  6. michael ark

    michael ark Master of the Pit

    I am cooking for 2 also and always have more room than i need.The gosm wide body is bigger than a master forge and bigger is better no cutting ribs in half here.As far as the Costco one i would save my money till it's not so new and price is lower.Get a wide body and spend the rest on min processed meat.[​IMG][​IMG]
  7. hoser45

    hoser45 Newbie

    Nice dinner for TWO! :) So you have the GOSM / Landmann Big Block? Seems like everyone loves it, but it's probably more than I budgeted, isn't it? Best source for purchasing?
  8. michael ark

    michael ark Master of the Pit

    No ,i have the mid size wide body .from wal-mart.Best source is the one you posted .I have never used more than 3 racks and it holds 4 .It turns out some great Q.Here is the finished ABT'S[​IMG]
  9. pineywoods

    pineywoods Smoking Guru Staff Member Administrator Group Lead SMF Premier Member

    Go with the one from Walmart and don't look back. I have two of them one at home and one at camp and they work great. I'll be ordering another one before Christmas as a gift for a family member
  10. hoser45

    hoser45 Newbie

    Are the Walmart gosm's a bit less well made for price point reasons?
  11. pineywoods

    pineywoods Smoking Guru Staff Member Administrator Group Lead SMF Premier Member

    One of mine is about 4 years old and the other is about a year old and I haven't had problems with either and both came from Walmart. The one I'll be ordering will be from there too
  12. smokinal

    smokinal Smoking Guru Staff Member Moderator OTBS Member ★ Lifetime Premier ★

    Sounds like a GOSM is the one to go with.
  13. hoser45

    hoser45 Newbie

  14. michael ark

    michael ark Master of the Pit

    Yes that's it.

Share This Page