Butts are done, but the party starts 11 hours from now. Should I shred and reheat? Let them sit in a cooler for as long as possible, shred, and crock pot it? Any other thoughts? I am baffled on this one. Normal one 8 pound butt takes me about 20 hours to smoke at 225 on my electric smoker. I put three 8 pounders in last night and I wake up with one at 208, one at 203, and one at 191 in just 12 hours. My party starts 11 hours from now.