First Time Smoking Turkey

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

motown45

Newbie
Original poster
SMF Premier Member
May 21, 2017
24
43
Detroit, Michigan
Hi everyone! First off, I want to say how thankful I am for this site. I have only just begun smoking this past year and it has been an awesome ride!

So I picked up a 21 and 3/4 lb Turkey from a local turkey farm. It is a free range chicken and fresh as can be. I was able to get a decent discount but it was by far the most expensive turkey I have ever paid for ($69). I brined the bird Tuesday night until about 9am Thanksgiving morning. I used 3 cups of brown sugar/1 cup of sea salt/ 1 teaspoon of #1pink salt for each gallon of water. I used 5 gallons of distilled water and placed the bird in a cooler with some ice cubes. Here is what he looks like:
IMG_1405.jpg


IMG_1407.jpg


After rinsing and drying the turkey I let it sit for 45 minutes to air dry. I then towel dried it one more time. I then cut up some butter and packed it in between the skin and the breast. I used one stick for this. I then rubbed on some olive oil and used a rub that consisted of a teaspoon each of Mickey and T's Gourmet Poultry rub, Fat Boy Sweet Rub, Coarse Ground Black Pepper and 3 TableSpoons of Brown Sugar. Here he is after that:
IMG_1408.jpg

IMG_1409.jpg


I then placed the turkey in a round pie tin. I filled the pie tin up with a half a can of Hoptronix Beer, 4 oz of Makers Mark Bourbon, 4 oz of Apple Cider Vinegar. I then quartered two small apples, two small pears, fresh garlic cloves, and half of a Vidalia Sweet Onion.

I loaded him up in my Masterbuilt 40 inch vertical smoker. I put him in at 10:28am and kept the temp at 290 the entire time. I used a mixture of apple and cherry chips at three points during the smoke. I used them as soon as I put the big guy in, one time after we passed the danger zone of 140, and then again when the IT was at 160. We passed the danger zone about 3 hrs in. I took him out at 3:10pm so just shy of five hours. Here he is:
IMG_1410.jpg


IMG_1413.jpg


Here it is being carved up and served. The smoke ring on the breast came out great!

IMG_1415.jpg


IMG_1416.jpg

IMG_1417.jpg


IMG_1418.jpg


So how did it taste? Full disclosure, I am not a fan of turkey. Quite frankly, I have NEVER had a turkey I liked. I smoked this for my family and then took it to my mother in laws house who cooked a turkey the normal way. It was a Butterball. I will say this, no one touched her turkey and mine was gone. It was the best turkey I have ever tasted. My wife whispered in my ear that this was the best turkey she has ever had and that she hopes I am prepared to do this every year. I then reminded her about the cost and she said, I don't care! Happy wife happy life, right!

Now I don't know if the turkey tasted so good due to the free range turkey it was or if it was because of the smoke. I plan on doing the exact same thing with a butterball next and will update you all!

Happy Thanksgiving to all of you!

Smoke On!
 
Thanks everyone! Just about everything I did minus a couple of rub ingredients, I did because of posts I read on here. This is a great forum. I appreciate all of you for keeping it up and for adding how you do things so that rookies like me can have great experiences smoking! Now off to the store to get some good bread and tomatoes for the Turkey sandwhich's at lunch!
 
Nice job, I kinda feel bad for you MIL since her's went untouched. A good gravy with a quality bread spell's open faced turkey sandwich ummmummm good.

Chris
 
I might have to try this over the weekend; any other pointers? This will be my first bird....

(New to smoking)
 
I might have to try this over the weekend; any other pointers? This will be my first bird....

(New to smoking)
Don't be shy, start your own thread and post specifics.

Motown, nice job! It is not because it was free range or that it was smoked, but usually the brining that really takes bird to another level.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky