Brining a pork shoulder thoughts????

Discussion in 'Pork' started by ajl80, Sep 19, 2013.

  1. ajl80

    ajl80 Newbie

    thoughts ideas about brining a pork shoulder? if so how long and with what spices?
  2. sqwib

    sqwib Smoking Guru OTBS Member

    IMHO No need to brine, but many folks do
  3. chef willie

    chef willie Master of the Pit OTBS Member

    I've done both ways....can't honestly say one is better than the other but brining a big shoulder, IMO, is a PITA. Need a huge bucket, an extra fridge, weights to keep it down etc etc. to make life easy. A good rub and temperature control should get you a delicious shoulder without brining. I will brine a turkey though...go figure.......Willie
  4. It's a matter of personal preference.
    I like to brine for flavor.
    Dry brining in a bag will eliminate the need for a large container and extra biggy.

  5. If you are going to brine - do it right and brine for upwards of a week. Brining for short periods of 24 or so hours does nothing for you. It takes time to get the good stuff into that big a chunk of meat (which is why so many inject).

    Here's my variation on Here Piggy Piggy Brine:

    In the snap lid container I use it is enough to cover two shoulders when I top it off with additional chilled apple cider.

    1 6 pack Vernors Ginger ale

    1 qt apple Cider

    1/4 cup celery salt

    1 cup sea salt

    4 Tbls diced dried red bell pepper

    2 Tbls rosemary

    6 Tbls light brown sugar

    1/2 Tbls cumin

    2 Tbls chili powder

    2 Tbls cayenne pepper

    1 tsp cinnamon

    2 tsp thyme

    1 tsp marjoram

    1 tsp fennel seed

    1 tsp sage

  6. blacklab

    blacklab Master of the Pit SMF Premier Member

    Might have to this on cornish game hens..........
  7. scootermagoo

    scootermagoo Smoking Fanatic

    I'll tell you what.  I'm lazy. [​IMG]   If I have to do flips and twists to prepare anything, I ain't gonna do it (within reason, of course).  That's just me.   I like to keep things simple.  Fresh butt with an apple juice/Bilbo's rub concoction to inject along with a nice coat of Bilbo's rub overnight and out onto the smoker early the next day or just straight on overnight.  No foil (I LOVE bark) and smoke to 203 degrees.  The results are tremendous, every single time.  I'll stick to the KISS method all day long.  I can't see the efforts of brining being worth the very small impact it makes on the final product.  People say that the brine enhances the tenderness and juiciness of the pork.................bull.  I will never believe that.  A butt can't turn out any other way if it is prepared properly, even without being injected or nuthin'.  And then if anything, the injection gets a little flavor on the inside of the butt, but probably does nothing for juiciness.  Just my 2 cents.

    I'm almost certain that in BBQs humble beginnings, nobody was bring anything.  Why break tradition?
  8. Well, in BBQ's humble beginnings they were eating real dinosaur 'bones'!!! :biggrin:


Share This Page