16 LB Rib roast

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

pit 4 brains

Master of the Pit
Original poster
OTBS Member
SMF Premier Member
Dec 16, 2009
2,557
618
Summerville, SC
So my in-laws asked if I would do a rib roast for Christmas if they bought it. I said sure, I'll put it on the rotisserie like i normally do. My mother in law just showed up with a 16 pound 18 inch roast. I'm not afraid yet, I just think this thing will bend my spit down and bog my motor.
The oven is out of the question as I want to do this outdoors. I have my Weber genesis Silver grill with a rotis or I can mount my big rotis on my Chargriller and remove my tuning tiles.
Has anyone rotised a side of meat this big? I normally cut back the fat cap, season and re-tie a three or four bone roast but this is long and the bones taper down which alarms me to un-even cooking.
I'm thinking to do it in my char griller with a strong fire on the bony end and a mild fire on the meaty end. I've always rotissed my rib roasts with two fires so that is not new to me, I was just concerned about getting it just below med rare the whole way across..

Any input?
 
sounds like you got a pretty good plan already but don't make the fire too hot on the thick end or you might pass mid rare.
 
I have never rotis'd anything, but I set up my old neigbor guy's snp with 1. he really liked the set up. His was able switch end going into the gear motor, so he could flip/ rotate ends. I argee, mediem rear or rear is the way to go, but is everyone going to want that. I always found it a bonus on 1 that big cuz you can get 1 end more done for those that like the meat crusified. Sounds very tastey, I will be doing a much smaller 1 sometime next week at my moms on here weber kettle.
 
I have not smoked or put a hunk of meat that size on a rotisserie either so your on your own. I would like to say that I will be watching for the Qview for my own learning experiance. So go for it and we will be here with knifes and forks in hand.
PDT_Armataz_01_12.gif
 
I have not rotisseried a rib roast, but every summer we cook about 7 full rib roasts for a huge party... And i tell you that is a monster of a cut of meat. You can always cut it in half or thirds too depending on your crowd and how done or not done they like their beef, and/or your cooking options. Just a suggestion. Good luck!
 
I think this is what I'm going to do. I'm gonna put the small-boned end in the Weber and cook it with gas so I can reg the temp and the large-boned end will go between some mesquite coals.

I assume Qview means take and post pictures so I'll do that.
 
Ok, I mounted up the spit and set the roast on it in one piece. The spit sagged a bit but it still spun under the weight. I'm assuming that when I skewer the spit rod through it, the drag will decrease and as it cooks the weight will diminish so i think I'm just gonna cook the whole enchilada and see what happens.

Now the big question. After taking it off the coals, should I leave the spit rod in while the roast rests (my inclination) or should I pull it right away so the meat can settle back and not leave a hole in the slices? I'm thinking that I'll lose a ton of juices if I pull it right away..
 
Pit - great job. Your prime looks delish! How long and at what temp did you end up cooking this beast?
Thanks,
Tracey
 
About 4 hours plus rest time. I had it directly over mesquite coals and my thermo on the char griller read about 225- 250 for most of the time. T started tossing in some new hot coals towards the end and had it about 325 or so for about the last 45 minnutes. Pulled it off when I got 135 in the center.
 
For your future big roast, I did a 17 lb boneless rib roast on my Weber Genesis rotisserie for Christmas Eve dinner and it worked fantastic. I had to remove the center burner plate cover thingy so the roast could rotate completely (covered the burner holes with foil). I put only the front burner on low and threw in cherry wood chips throughout the cook, which took about 4 hrs. I would definitely do that again the same way as it turned out so good.
 
I have had good luck with smaller ones like 3 and 4 bones in the weber. There's just something about what mesquite coals do when the beef fat hits them that makes it ohhhhh so good. I had the spit set up on the weber just for emergency sake. I wish I could use the same spit rod for both the weber and the char griller but no go.
I did check to see if the forks are interchangeable and they are so next time I might cut it in half and turn two roasts over three fires in the char griller.
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
Clicky