What if I don't want my ribs 'fall off the bone'?

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

elohel

Smoke Blower
Original poster
Jul 2, 2011
88
10
Rochester, MN
I'm cooking some ribs for dinner tomorrow while I smoke my brisket. I've gotten a good taste down on my ribs, but my family complains that the meat just falls off the bone and they really aren't 'ribs' anymore. Is there any tried and true method to making tender ribs that hold to the bone?

Thanks fellas
 
Don't Foil...Smoke until when you lift them at or near the mid point they bend 90 degrees without breaking and a tooth pick inserted goes in easy...It still will take 5-6 hours at 225*F...JJ
 
It works for me. I quit foiling after my first two rib smokes. 

For me it's:

Set it.

Forget it.

No peeking, spritzing, or foiling.
 
Looking forward to the Qview 
biggrin.gif
 
Welp, I finally got them done haha. I took a before picture of the ribs before they cooked, but they didn't save for some reason. I really liked the texture of these better without the foil.

2f9ea600_2agt7xl.jpg


3e742ab1_15d8ieb.jpg


They turned out alright.. but I'm having the same issue that I've been having since I got the MES and wood pellets. I don't really taste _any_ smoke flavor. None. I smoked them for about 3 hours (total cook time of 6.5 hours), and there was enough smoke that I should've tasted it. I used a little pecan, mostly apple. Should I try a wood with more bite next time? My only issue is that I have tons and tons of apple, oak and pecan pellets, but I'm not really getting anything with the apple/pecan it seems.

Any advice would be wonderful. Thanks
 
Last edited:
I have not used pellets *yet* but i think the primary wood needs to be stronger to stand up with the rub/mop/sauce of most ribs. I generally use hickory(say 50 pct) and apple and cherry for the other 50 pct. of course I am going just by size of the chunks :) who know what pct of smoke it is. but it turns out mild, not too strong but it is noticeable. maybe with pellets you need all hickory or maybe mesquite?
 
I found if you foil for less then 2 hours you get a firmer rib. I have foiled for 1 hour b4 and the ribs turned out good.
 
elohel, evening...  Do you have the ribs dry on the outside ???  Smoke doesn't stick and penetrate to water too well....  Try drying them in front of a fan for 1/2 - 1 hour before they go in the smoker..... Dave

Smoke or no smoke they sure look delicious....
 
Messing around with the foil time will help.

I like mine cooked slower and without foil.  A bit of a tug there.  My other half likes fall off the bone and gunked up with sauce. 

No problem?  I split the rack.  She gets hers, I get mine.
biggrin.gif


Good luck and good smoking.
 
Apple and Pecan are some what mild to begin with and if they are not Todds pellets, they may be mixed with Oak or Alder which makes them is even more mild. Blend in some Hickory and run smoke the entire time. Smoke particles will continue to stick to the meat and gain flavor it as long as it is being generated...JJ
 
I'll certainly give that a try, thanks for the suggestions. Your cook method/time was spot on! Very juicy/well cooked ribs.
 
elohel,

Could you please change your avatar?  Every time I see it I get distracted and forget why I am here.  (just kidding.  please leave it!)

drool.gif
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Latest posts

Hot Threads

Clicky