Bulk Rub: buy or make?

golfpro2301

Smoking Fanatic

Original poster

Jun 6, 2012

535

145

Jacksonville, FL

• Aug 11, 2015

• #1

Hello everyone. Football season is right around the corner and I have been selected to cater my local highschool football games. Will be doing pork sandwiches, boiled peanuts, and hot dogs. Probably be doing 300-500 sandwiches depending on the game. I have made and bought many rubs for competition and I found Everglades rub to be really good and you can doctor it pretty easily. Have won most of my awards with that rub. I have 8 games I have to cook for this year and was thinking about getting the Case of rub from Everglades for $140. This is (5) 5lb jugs or doing a bulk batch of Jeff's Rub. I started out with Jeff's rub a few years ago when I started competing and really liked it. havent made it in a long time. After buying all the spices which do you think would be more cost effective. I plan on cooking 15-18 butts each game.

 

venture

Smoking Guru

OTBS Member

Aug 1, 2008

6,948

73

Central California

• Aug 11, 2015

• #2

For bulk rub, I prefer to make, seal tightly and store for numerous future uses.

For some items there are perfectly good products you can purchase.  The problem with them is that you can spend a lot of money finding the ones you like for different applications. The purchased ones also have a limited shelf life if not properly stored, and with all, it is only for a reasonable period of time.

One man's opinion.

Good luck and good smoking.

 

chef jimmyj

Gone but not forgotten. RIP

OTBS Member

SMF Premier Member

★ Lifetime Premier ★

May 12, 2011

22,172

7,150

• Aug 12, 2015

• #3

That Everglades Rub is $5.60 per Pound. I don't think you can do better making Jeff's Rub unless you find a wholesale source where the main spices are in the $3-4 per pound range. At Myspicesage.com, for 5Lb of Paprika is $50 ($10/Lb), Granulated Garlic is $45.25 ($9/Lb). Making your own may not be cost effective here...JJ

 

S

sfprankster

Master of the Pit

May 6, 2015

1,574

292

• Aug 12, 2015

• #4

Here's a source for spices/herbs in San Francisco that has reasonable prices SF Herb Co.  

Or an organic source that isn't overly pricey Mt Rose Herbs 

 

wimpy69

Smoking Fanatic

Aug 4, 2014

976

205

Lower Bucks,PA / Surf City, LBI NJ

• Aug 12, 2015

• #5

All valid points above. Mainly shelf life and cost effective. Brown sugar can harden which can add extra work when applying. But overall ease of application and storage over the season makes the $140 worth it. It's proven before in comp and what you don't use is still sealed. JMHO.

 

mummel

Master of the Pit

Apr 8, 2015

2,294

64

Massachusetts

• Aug 12, 2015

• #6

Im a big fan of the Pork Barrel BBQ rub they have at Costco for $5.  Only has 12% salt.

 

golfpro2301

Smoking Fanatic

Original poster

Thread starter

Jun 6, 2012

535

145

Jacksonville, FL

• Aug 12, 2015

• #7

I will have to try that Pork Barrel rub. I went ahead and ordered case of Everglades. I love that rub. sweet with decent heat at the end. Now the key is making it last for a while. I cant remember how much I used on the 100 person party I catered a month ago. I know I coated them pretty good but may sacrifice a little coverage on these. 

 

chef jimmyj

Gone but not forgotten. RIP

OTBS Member

SMF Premier Member

★ Lifetime Premier ★

May 12, 2011

22,172

7,150

• Aug 12, 2015

• #8

wimpy69 said:

All valid points above. Mainly shelf life and cost effective. Brown sugar can harden which can add extra work when applying. But overall ease of application and storage over the season makes the $140 worth it. It's proven before in comp and what you don't use is still sealed. JMHO.

Click to expand...

Drying the Brown Sugar eliminates any clumping issues. Spread on a sheet pan and left out overnight does well or I bake it about 15 minutes at 200°F does a quick job...JJ

 

jcollins

Smoking Fanatic

Dec 16, 2014

580

32

Del Rio TN

• Aug 12, 2015

• #9

I like to vac seal and freeze my home made rub if it has brown sugar in it keeps it from clumping up but on the other hand you could just make up your rub store it in an air tight container without the brown sugar mixed in yet then when your ready to use it just add the sugar to it but at the costs Chef JJ listed above it just dont make since to waste money and time with a homemade rub if you can buy one you like just as good for less

 

jarjarchef

Master of the Pit

OTBS Member

Sep 30, 2010

3,155

117

Central Florida

• Aug 15, 2015

• #10

How many pounds do you feel you need to make? Depending on how elaborate your rub recipe is you should be able to get most items at a restaurant depot or style store. $5 a pound for a rub is a bit high too me for a rub you need to spend more to doctor...... I would make my own....

 

jarjarchef

Master of the Pit

OTBS Member

Sep 30, 2010

3,155

117

Central Florida

• Aug 15, 2015

• #11

Sorry forgot the brown sugar part.......
As Chef said you can dry it and that works very well. I removed brown sugar a long time ago and now use sugar in the raw instead......

 

golfpro2301

Smoking Fanatic

Original poster

Thread starter

Jun 6, 2012

535

145

Jacksonville, FL

• Aug 15, 2015

• #12

I only doctor it up for chicken. I use a another rub with it on ribs and just use it plain for pork so I will be using rub only for these games no doctoring. I priced it and couldnt make Jeffs rub for cheaper. I can get spices cheap online but shipping cost will kill me