Sunday funday = my first butt

  • Some of the links on this forum allow SMF, at no cost to you, to earn a small commission when you click through and make a purchase. Let me know if you have any questions about this.
SMF is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

dirtyduc83

Fire Starter
Original poster
Jan 2, 2015
50
23
Seattle, WA
Well actually it was a 10 lb picnic shoulder. Started it up 12:30am rubbed down with mustard and a generous coating of pappy's choice reduced sodium seasoning. Been using the stuff on everything...found it on Amazon with good reviews.

Put it in the MES40 with mailbox mod and amnps with lumberjack Oak, hickory, cherry blend (my new favorite). It went overnight at 225. This morning around 8:00 it was at 153...still a ways to go. Decided not to wrap as I had great results with a no foil brisket.

It finally hit 200 IT at 6:30pm about 18 hrs total. I wrapped it and popped it in to a 170 degree oven. Once in I killed the heat. Rested in there for about an hour. I started pulling at around 7:30pm with my newly acquired bear claws. Bones came out clean and if it weren't for the bark would have fallen apart as I tried to move it from the foil.

It was perfectly tender, great bark and smokiness. Threw it on a soft roll with a little bbq sauce. My gf said it was the best pulled pork she has ever had. I had to agree. I'm excited this first pulled pork effort turned out so well. No more sub par restaurant pulled pork for me.

Some qview:

 
That looks tasty.
Looks-Great.gif
 
DD83, nice looking PP, did you use a finishing sauce ?
DD83, nice looking PP, did you use a finishing sauce ?

No finishing sauce on it. I might mix one up tonight since i'll be reheating a few lbs of it for the work potluck tomorrow.

Thanks all for checking out my Q. Excited about the results i'm getting with the MES and AMNPS.
 
Mixed up some of SoFlaQuers finishing sauce and splashed some in when I warmed up the pork for a sandwich. The added tang is a nice contrast on the rich pulled pork. Topped it with a little coleslaw on a soft bun.

Any preferences on store bought sauce? I've always liked sweet baby rays. Haven't ventured in to making my own yet.
 
Mixed up some of SoFlaQuers finishing sauce and splashed some in when I warmed up the pork for a sandwich. The added tang is a nice contrast on the rich pulled pork. Topped it with a little coleslaw on a soft bun.

Any preferences on store bought sauce? I've always liked sweet baby rays. Haven't ventured in to making my own yet.
No store bought here. Just jeff's sauce.
 
That needs to be on the cover of BBQ magazine   Fantastic Color

Gary
 
SmokingMeatForums.com is reader supported and as an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.

Hot Threads

Clicky